Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Study: Google has the power to fix elections

Update : 13 May 2014, 10:19 AM

Altering Google search results can pose a real threat to democracy as it has a major impact on the voting preferences of undecided voters and could swing a close election, says a study by a research institute in Vista, California, USA. In the experiment, researchers at the American Institute for Behavioral Research and Technology (AIBRT), deliberately manipulated the voting preferences of undecided voters in the national Lok Sabha election in India, the largest democratic election in history, with over 800 million eligible voters. They did this by randomly assigning undecided voters who had not yet voted (recruited through print advertisements, online advertisements, and online subject pools) to one of three groups in which search rankings favoured either Mr Gandhi, Mr Kejriwal, or Mr Modi. About 2,000 eligible voters from 26 of India's 28 states (age range 18 to 70) participated in the study- not enough to affect the election's outcome.In research conducted last year in the US, researchers found that search rankings biased in favour of a candidate could push the preferences of undecided voters towards that candidate by 15 per cent or more. The new study shows that votes in India can easily be pushed towards one candidate or another by about 12 percent- double that amount in some demographic groups - enough to determine the outcomes of many close races. "This is a very serious matter - a real threat to democracy," said Dr Robert Epstein, lead researcher in the study and Senior Research Psychologist at the American Institute for Behavioural Research and Technology in California. "If two candidates were both trying to push their rankings higher, they would be competing, and that's fine. But if Google, which has a monopoly on search in India, were to favour one candidate, it could easily put that candidate in office by manipulating search rankings, and no one could counter what they were doing. "Even if without human intervention the company's search algorithm favoured one candidate, thousands of votes would still be driven to that candidate," said Epstein.

The new study shows that votes in India can easily be pushed towards one candidate or another by about 12 percent

In the new study real search rankings and web pages were used, and people were asked to research all the candidates just as they would on Google. The only difference between the groups was the order in which the search results were displayed. The new study suggests that biased search rankings can be used to fix the outcome of races in India in which the winner is projected to win by a margin up to 2.9 per cent. This can be done just by influencing undecided voters who use the internet - a small but important group of voters that is sure to grow in coming years, researchers said. Worldwide, the researchers said, upwards of 25 per cent of national elections are won by margins under 3 percent. The study also shows that certain demographic groups are especially vulnerable. The voting preferences of 19 per cent of women over 35 were shifted in the study, as were the voting preferences of 18 per cent of voters who were unemployed.

Top Brokers