Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Safety nets do work

Update : 28 May 2014, 07:58 PM

I am privileged to have enjoyed very good relationships with almost all finance ministers and secretaries in the last two decades. Be it M Saifur Rahman, SAMS Kibria, Akbar Ali Khan, Mirza Aziz, or Muhith – one thing I have seen in common in all, is an eagerness to reduce poverty and help out the marginalised.

Many development partners earn a lot of praise for social protection programs in Bangladesh. No matter whether we are dismayed about the success of these social safety nets or social protection, Bangladesh remains a champion in reducing ultra-poverty through multi-faceted social support programs. Apart from the government, through its Social Safety Net Programs (SSNPs), many NGOs have also contributed significantly in this space.

Ironically, Bangladesh has an almost 15 million “passenger population” riding on the back of the productive forces doing almost nothing.

There are, at present, four types of SSNPs in Bangladesh. These are: Employment generation program (employment for the poorest of the poor, food for work, vulnerable group development, and such), cash transfer (allowances for widows, destitute women, etc), conditional cash transfer (stipend for primary school students, school nutrition program, etc), and emergency relief (eg open market sale or the feeding of vulnerable groups).

Absence of comprehensive data makes it difficult to track the expenditure of SSNPs. In 2006, World Bank estimated that during the period between FY1996-97 and FY2004-05, on an average, the government expenditure on SSNPs was to the tune of 0.8% of the GDP and 5.7% of the total public expenditure. In fact, the definition of SSNP is undergoing several changes. For example, a pension for retired government employees and their families was being operated, but was not recognised when a more comprehensive data on SSNP budget was presented in FY2006-07.

In FY2010-11, this program accounted for 20% of the total safety net budget. Efforts towards widening the SSNPs in recent years are evident in Bangladesh. New programs are being included. Budgetary allocations for SSNPs as a share of total budget increased from 8.4% in FY2006-07 to 14.8% in FY2010-11. As a share of GDP, allocation for SSNPs also doubled in the last five years, reaching 2.5% in FY2010-11 compared to FY2006-07. The government, the ministry of planning to be precise, has done some extensive research to understand the “target market” better and widen the beneficiary net.

The Sixth Five Year Plan (SFYP) document has proposed increasing public expenditure on SSNPs to that of 3% of the GDP in FY2014-15. Budget for fiscal 2014 has allocated Tk253.71bn (or Tk25,371cr) for SSNPs, which is 11.4% of the total budget and 2.13% of Bangladesh’s GDP. Even with the recent rise, Bangladesh seems to be spending far less than other regions. The World Bank showed that, on an average, South Asian economies spent 4% of the GDP in SSNPs, whereas the expenditure of East Asia and the Pacific was about 8% of the GDP. Incidentally, many developed countries are also seen putting up large sums towards building social protection.

With visible results, the ministry of finance is reportedly ready to come down more strongly on poverty. Some are of the opinion that the target market should be squeezed to make this more effective. Some say the allocation should be higher to make this worthwhile. However, most feel that only the ministry of finance will not be able to ensure positive impacts much unless line ministries like food, agriculture, health, education, women, and children’s affairs come up with a fitting, performance-driven execution plan. Increasingly, monitoring is becoming the most important issue to make sure the right target market is being served and that the money is not being used to buy luxury items for the “rural landlords.”

People these days talk about decentralisation, since commuting takes much time and often seriously deters implementation. Many have focused on quality expenditure management, monitoring, and evaluation of the programs at the ministry and directorate levels. Expected implementation is also influenced by overt political intervention at the ground level. We also need to decentralise these with a performance stick at the Union Parishad level and make sure they reach out further to the target market. Major issues related to SSNPs still remain to be – targeting areas, targeting the deserving poor, indentify the required amount of allowance, and impact assurance. The World Bank study shows 60% of the SSNP beneficiaries are not poor. Therefore leakage reduction is critical. Under-capacitated or non-committal local government institution, rent-seeking middlemen, politicisation, and governance failures are not allowing the benefits to reach the real target segment and ensure efficacy of the programs, despite much eagerness at the top.

Employment-generation programs should guarantee jobs. Bangladesh has been trying to expand the guaranteed job days. The party in power can think of passing a law in the parliament like the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act in India. Modi’s government has reiterated its commitment to rural employment generation and is refocusing on the mentioned act put into action in 2005. Efficiency and effectiveness of SSNPs should be increased. At the same time we would like to see diversity in the program architecture as well. Allocation on SSNPs may be increasing every year but with regard to GDP it is decreasing.

Safety net programs should continue, and Bangladesh should be seen as a real test case for development through reducing poverty, and rural employment generation, by its peers and partners. Irrespective of party affiliation, all public representatives should get to see “distribution economics” working. Political accountability, integrated impact assessment, and program quality assurance can take this country on its next trajectory in terms of growth.

Top Brokers