The last week of this November and the important meeting on November 25 will be remembered in the historical evolution of Europe not only for its geo-strategic and economic implications, but also for its social denotations pertaining to citizens’ rights.
It saw final discussion and agreement on two separate documents drafted and agreed to by negotiators from the UK and the EU within that period. The first one termed as the withdrawal agreement, set out the terms of Brexit in the wake of a landmark June 2016 referendum.
At 585 pages, it dealt with citizens’ rights, the mechanism pertaining to the controversial issue of preventing a hard border between Ireland and Northern Ireland, and details on the length of Britain’s transition period, set to last from March 2019 until December 2020.
The second document related to a political declaration, an aspirational, non-legally binding text that sets out the terms of the future relationship between the EU and the UK over 26 pages.
It deals with ambitions for a future trading relationship, as well as close ties on foreign policy, criminal justice, law enforcement, security, and defense.
It is being hoped by both the EU and UK that the mutually agreed to political declaration will be the basis for a trade agreement, to be hammered out during a 21-month transition period that is due to kick-off after March 29, 2019 and will last till December 31, 2020. The UK will need to abide by all EU rules, but will lose membership of its institutions.
The draft withdrawal agreement says the transition can be extended, but both the UK and EU must agree to any extension and the decision must be taken before July 1, 2020.
The 585-page document also focuses on how much money the UK must pay to the EU as a settlement (often dubbed the divorce bill), details of the transition period and citizens’ rights. It also covers the so-called principle of “backstop” -- a last-resort option to maintaining an open border on the island of Ireland in the event the UK leaves the EU without securing a trade deal.
This would avoid the need for bringing back physical border checks. The backstop would also involve a temporary single customs territory, encompassing Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK, effectively keeping the whole of the UK in the EU customs union -- until both the EU and UK agree that it is no longer necessary.
Chris Morris of the BBC has made some important observations about the proposed UK Brexit deal.
The first relates to the financial settlement (or “divorce bill”) that the UK will need to pay to the EU to settle all of its obligations. This is expected to be at least 39 billion pounds and it will have to be paid over a number of years as UK’s financial contribution towards the annual budget of the EU budget.
This amount, as expected, has become a cause of controversy among many Brexit supporters.
The next point is regarding citizens’ rights. Efforts are underway so that UK citizens in the EU, and EU citizens in the UK, can retain their residency and social security rights after Brexit, be able to take up residency in another EU country during the transition period, including the UK, and be allowed to stay in that country after the transition and also if anyone stays in the same EU country for five years be allowed to apply for permanent residence.
The negotiations are causing an enormous amount of anxiety and uncertainty as British citizens in other EU countries still do not know whether they will be able to work across borders in the future.
Economists have also drawn attention to the continuing problem being faced with regard to Northern Ireland by the UK. They have noted that a long-term trade deal has to be agreed to by the end of 2020 that avoids a hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.
If this is not done, Northern Ireland will be in a deeper customs relationship with the EU than the rest of the UK.
Another issue that is creating concern is rights associated with fishing. This relates to access to EU fishing in UK waters.
Chris Morris has observed that fishing has been left out of plans for a single customs territory because several EU countries have objected to the idea that UK fish produce would be allowed unimpeded access to EU markets, without any corresponding guarantee that EU boats would be granted access to UK fishing waters.
The fifth issue that has drawn attention of the legal practitioners relates to the resolution of disputes. It is being pointed out that the UK will remain under the European Court of Justice (ECJ) jurisdiction during the period of transition and this might create difficulties in efforts to resolve a dispute through arbitration.
The next aspect that is continuing to draw attention is what future UK-EU relationship might be towards existing protocols pertaining to Gibraltar and British military bases in Cyprus. Spain’s Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez has already warned that Spain will oppose the Brexit agreement if the future status of Gibraltar is not clarified.
This has led him to demand that Madrid should be able to directly negotiate with London in this regard. Theresa May has however reiterated that Gibraltar’s present controversial status is not likely to change.
CNN has noted that all 27 remaining EU leaders, despite differing opinions, have signed off Britain’s Brexit agreement -- the Withdrawal Agreement and the Political Declaration with mixed emotions at a special summit in Brussels on November 25 -- but the deal’s real test is yet to come. The process will now require the assent of the British parliament and subsequent ratification by the European parliament.
This debate within the Brexit matrix has led critics to express their concern that the UK, because of the latest agreement might find itself in a situation where it will have to continue to follow EU rules for an indefinite time without having any say over them.
Muhammad Zamir is a former ambassador, and an analyst specialized in foreign affairs, right to information, and good governance. He can be reached at [email protected].



