BRAC James P Grant School of Public Health, BRAC University, Department of Women and Gender Studies, University of Dhaka, Sangat Feminist Network, Dhaka and One Billion Rising Bangladesh joined together in hosting the SamaBhav (Equanimity) travelling film festival at Chayyanaut on August 21-22.
The film festival, being held in 45 screenings over 10 locations across India, and also in Dhaka and Kathmandu with local collaborators during February to August 2022, is featuring from a package of 13 national and international short films, documentaries and feature films on gender.
These films cover a wide range of gender matters – from various forms of gender-based discrimination / violence against women to transphobia to breaking the gender binaries and toxic Masculinity.
Award-Winning and notable Films The Great Indian Kitchen, Natkhat, Hridoy Bosot, Untying The Knot (Bangladesh), Maida, Black Roses and Red Dresses, Bhaap, Sunday, Darling (Pakistan), Tuloni Bia are among the notable films that would be screened.
The inauguration event was held on day one of the festival, Khushi Kabir, Co ordinator of One Billion Rising Bangladesh and Advisor of Sangat - A Feminist Network, Secretariat opened the event, introducing members from the festival’s partner organisers - Dr Sabina Faiz Rashid, Dean of BRAC James P Grant School of Public Health, BRAC University and Umme Busra Fateha Sultana, Chair of Department of Women and Gender Studies, Dhaka University. The Guest Shameem Akhter, renowned film Director spoke whilst Harish Sadani of Men Against Violence and Abuse from India and Founder of the SamaBhav Film festival concluded.
Khushi Kabir mentioned how Indian poet Kamla Bhasin had requested the festival in Bangladesh. These two days were dedicated to the memory of Kamla Bhasin.
Animated discussions over screening of films played a key part of the Program. Guest discussants included : Sara Zaker, Shameem Akhter, Amitabh Reza Choudhary, Taslima Akhter, Barrister Sara Hossain, Dr Gitiara Nasreen, Dr Firdous Azim, Nurun Nahar, Nasrin Siraj Anni, Sharmin Karmin, Nazia Zebin and Guests from India Nelson Deb and Harish Sadani from Men Against Violence and Abuse.
Discussions
Toxic Masculinity
After the movie ‘’Natkhat’’ co directed by the Bollywood Actor, Vidya Balan, who was also starred in the movie raised interesting points from the audience regarding domestic violence and the effect of toxic masculinity on the child character, the discussion was led by Harish Sadani from Men Against Violence on ‘’Toxic Masculinity’’. Harish mentioned how toxic masculinity creeps in when one wants to remain in power by causing pain to others, how can we engage with those inflicting the pain, how the perpetrators can become part of the conversation.
Violence Against Women
The film ‘’Untying the Knot’’ by Director Zanna Shammi was screened for the first time in Bangladesh, showing the realities of four different women, the central protagonist was Rumana Manzur, a teacher in Dhaka University, who had been studying in Canada, on a visit back to Bangladesh, she was blinded and disfigured by her then husband, as a reaction to her filing for a divorce. The other protagonists included a woman who was enduring an abusive marriage, a recent divorcee and a woman who shared her story of sexual abuse when she was younger and shared her views on leading her life the way she wanted without the impositions on her freedom, which she felt marriage placed on her. The guest discussants after the film was Sara Hossain, Lawyer at the Supreme Court and honourary
Executive Director for Bangladesh and Legal Aid Services Trust and one of the protagonists of the movie. Sara Hossain shared how there was much organising for the justice of Rumana Manzur on the ground in Canada and in Bangladesh. Sara highlighted the benefits in Canada compared to a woman seeking justice in Bangladesh, if a woman were to pursue a divorce or leave an abusive marriage, she would have to face many obstacles; the lack of support or services, she might not necessarily be able to live with her family or receive housing support. Also, as the protagonist was brave, she found her own agency to receive assistance from a legal aid organisation in Bangladesh, the law could only protect those who could reach out for assistance. The protagonist shared her experience of the organisation she reached out to, how she received support and felt confident to pursue her own education, after feeling dehumanized by the abuse.
The movie, ‘’Black Roses and Red Dresses’’, a documentary style movie about the day to day lives of acid survivors and the pain in coming to terms with why they were the victims of such heinous act of violence was screened at the start of the second day of the festival. Upon reflection, a student shared how she did not realise the depth of pain a survivor had to endure, after watching the movie she felt more compelled to include such survivors into society, to include and to understand. Nurun Nahar, the guest discussant after this movie, an acid attack survivor herself who now works at Action Aid, became emotional watching the movie, thanking the Director for bringing this issue to light. She shared her story with the audience, how people in her home town were negative about her coming out to public events, how difficult it was for her to heal mentally. It was not until she met the late Nasreen Parveen Huq from Narripokkho, a women’s organisation, who played a pivotal role in her healing. Nurun Nahar shared how Nasreen Huq encouraged her to study. She mentioned how the positive and supportive words from people in the organisation, helped her to gain strength. The sudden death of Nasreen Huq, spurred her to provide the same support and reach out to other survivors of acid attacks. She started to visit the Dhaka hospitals to stand by the survivors, she wrote to around 200 survivors and organised a National forum, where survivors could share their thoughts and feelings with other survivors. She even organized a runway show for Acid Survivors and had taken this show to Action Aid London to highlight this issue.
Dr Gitiara Nasreen, Professor from the Department of Mass Communication and Journalism of Dhaka University commended the travelling festival for uniting people from the South Asian region in recognizing these issues, together, they can also find solutions for these problems. Through film, sound, scenes and the work of the actors and directors, the audience could empathise with those who were enduring domestic abuse. Dr Gitiara, referring to a question the main protagonist, ‘’Reshmi’’, kept asking in the movie, ‘’Unhay Essa Kyu Kiya’’ (Why did he do this), responded that throwing acid was possibly the worst level of violence against a woman, to dehumanize them. Nurun Nahar also mentioned the increase in the number of cases in 2022, regarding land matters. How rapes during genocides where women were targeted as a strategy to weaken a country. Dr Gitiara recognized technology as a powerful tool, where people could connect, empathise and feel and how networking was essential for victims of different levels of abuse in order to address this with a greater solution.
Gender Inequalities and Patriarchy
Taslima Akhter, Renowned Photographer and Workers Rights Activist appeared as a discussant to review the film ‘’Under Construction’’, Directed by Rubaiyat Hossain. The film followed the central characters experiences and day to day challenges as an ageing actress living in Bangladesh, she focused on issues around her; such as the misery of garment workers and the film highlighted her lonely life as a suburban housewife, her husband was disappointed she was not keen on having a child and her mother would hint at disappointment for being an actress, ‘’a bad girl’’. The film showed the influences on the mother, the religious and societal perceptions of her daughter being an actress, her husband having left her for an actress and her struggle to maintain her expenses. Desertion and infidelity are also a major reality for women despite class.
Diversity
The award winning short film from Pakistan, ‘’Darling’’, shared the journey of a transgender male who auditioned to get into an erotic dance show. The second film in this cluster was ‘’Hridoy Bosot’’, showing the emotional journey of a trans gender man having a sex change operation and the effect on his family members. Guest Discussants : Dr Firdous Azim, Member of Narripokkho and Professor of English and Humanities at BRAC University noted how ‘’Darling’’ was a poignant film, where there was an interplay of the roles of between both genders, male and female and the dynamic of the ‘’games’’ played in the entertainment industry. She also mentioned the beautiful portrayal of the family relationships in ‘’Hridoy Boshot’’, the relationships between family members and the main protagonist, his love for them and being aware of the difficulties and challenges they face because of him. It showed a very loving family who wanted to accept his sexuality. Harish Sadani mentioned before the screening of Hridoy Bosot (Journey of the Heart), how this was highly acclaimed, the first film ever to capture the process of a sex change operation. Akramul Momen, (they/them/theirs) is a trans-disciplinary artist, author and journalist, commented on how both the films touched on the difficulties he had faced, referring to ‘’Darling’’ in the entertainment industry. How he played the role of a ‘’woman’’ but is treated like a man and how he wanted to dress as a woman in a dancing troupe for classic dancing, Bharatnatyam, which was not accepted, where the other transgender men dressed as men. He wanted to explore with jewellery or the sari but was rejected from the troupe.
He mentioned in the rural areas where people are still not ready to accept non binary genders or his attire. How his family had told him to go to Dhaka and dress how he wanted. He did say the conversations in Bangladesh have become increasingly positive. Class and privilege was brought up by both speakers, Dr Firdous emphasised the option of the sex change operation, was not available to everyone.
Audience members raised crucial points regarding the challenges for the transgender community in Bangladesh, one student of the University of Dhaka, Department of Women and Gender Studies ‘’we are talking about the importance of policy but we need more dialogue and awareness to change mindsets for a progressive community’’. Another student shared that she is researching on the informal economy and the lack of job opportunities for transgender community, she highlighted that the Government are providing a stipend of only 600 BDT per month, for the ‘Hijra’ population – was that sufficient?
Dr Firdous raised the issue regarding LGBTI being used as an umbrella term – interestingly we did not talk about the ‘’transwoman’’ or the lesbian population who are further cornered in the community. She spoke about Rabindranath Tagore writing about gender politics and how Rituparno Ghosh addressed it through his interpretations. Akramul Momen asked whether the gender diverse communities are being represented in Bangladesh? ‘’We cannot always feel comfortable with the rainbow flag. We have a lot of cultural history regarding gender fluidity.’’
Sexuality
‘’My Mother’s Girlfriend’’ was indeed a festival favourite for many, for others an unusually shocking situation! Arun Fulara is the writer for both films shown in this segment and ‘’Hello’’ a 5 minute delve into the mind of an aged man who craves the touch of his young barber. Both movies exposed intimate desires which are hidden behind the closet, especially so in the South Asian region. The main character in ‘’My Mother’s Girlfriend’’, is found out by her adult son, she is seeing a Muslim lady, both working class women have a wonderful on screen chemistry and friendship. Perhaps their physical intimacy was a little risqué for Chayyanaut on a Monday afternoon! The son tried to talk his mother out of this
‘’madness’’ after confronting her, she was unafraid to live her life the way she wanted. At the end, her son met her partner and in a great juxtaposition, the audience could feel and empathise what the son was feeling but at the same time, display how his mother’s girlfriend loved and cared for his mother. Panelist who does not want to be quoted expressed enjoyed the capture of the middle aged characters and their desire as their representation is not seen in the media. Nasrin Siraj Anni, Anthropologist and Documentary Film maker, talked about her movie on the sexuality of migrant workers in the city ‘’Lookachuri’’ (Hide and Seek), recently she has been travelling around Bangladesh, screening and engaging in discussion regarding sexuality. Anni responded to the theme of this segment and the movies shown, ‘’Is it time to break the taboos around sexuality’’? ‘’We talk about sexual violence but we do not talk about sexuality, desires or pleasure. Is it time to break the taboos?’’. ‘’Women are seen primarily through their reproduction function. We do not have conversations around womens’s pleasure/sexuality.’’ Interestingly she shared, when men talk about sexuality – we criticize, men for being perverted. The movie ‘’Sunday’’ could make us feel uncomfortable, however, a man can have a crush on his barber? Women talking about pleasure is still a taboo as well. Both these films being screened in Bangladesh, society does not allow people to explore their sexuality. Sexuality is more than experimental, there is limited scope for conversation regarding sexuality.
Discussant who wishes not to be named added the space for women to experiment is limited for women. Anni responded sexual objectivity and consent are also underlying issues which are not spoken about. An audience member asked, ‘’why do boys and girls need to think about experimentation?’’, to which Anni replied, people need to explore their identity, in the Bengali culture, mother’s try to prevent their adolescent children from relationships, ‘’bhool hoy jaabey’’ (A ‘’mistake’’ might occur), she said, ‘’bhool hok’’, make mistakes – that is a phase of growth. Also the mindset, it the girl has different partners, ‘’kharap naari’’, ‘’bad girl’’. Both discussants spoke about the space for experimentation is not thought about and perhaps does not exist in our society. An audience member asked, ‘’is that space necessary’’?
Interestingly, the audience member spoke about the scenes in movies where the bride is sat under the bed in a veil and the man lifts the veil, as if the woman is a sexual object – Anni asked, why don’t we see it the other way around? Are we ready to perceive a woman may have desires herself? Referringg to the film Sunday is shown in festivals for this space. There is no space to be radical.
Closing Discussion after Great Indian Kitchen
One review regarding the Great Indian Kitchen is quoted ‘’ Startling, scathing, stunning take-down of patriarchy and its eternal sidekick, religion’’ The Great Indian Kitchen is Malayalam Movie by Jeo Baby, a 100 minute movie for the grand finale. The film approaches the issues of patriarchy and religion affecting a new bride, at the start is seen enjoying dance in a study, marries into a very traditional, religious family. The audience is taken through a laborious journey of her daily routine and domestic tasks, in a repetitive manner, from showing the washing of the dishes one by one, wiping the table after the men have eaten, cleaning the drain in the kitchen with her cringing face. The first 40 minutes of the movie passes this way, without barely any dialogue, the woman is shocked to learn during menstruation, she has to sleep on the floor separate to everyone else for its duration. Her needs or desires are flippantly ignored. By the end, she has had enough.
After the movie, the audience members raised certain points, on student stepped up and recalled the life of her mother, the everyday routine on repeat. The film also highlighted the influence of religion and how people need to adjust it to their lives but not over their basic rights.
Another audience member shared her parents expecting her to do all the domestic work and chores at home and letting her younger brother, ‘’off the hook’’ , when approaching her mother, why can’t her brother contribute? The mother says, ‘’he cannot do it’’ (Parey na). Certain misogyny and patriarchal values are still in our households, the situation will not change if men and women with the patriarchal mindset do not recognize this themselves.
A Male student asked why is there a lack of movies showing a positive depiction of women wanting to be ‘’Shongshari’’, ‘’passionate about household chores and the home’’. Film Director, Amitabh Reza, responded that the gender problem lies with men, ‘’Does a man want to be shongshari’’? Sara Zaker, spoke to the audience members, complimenting them for their post film comments and their thoughts, she said that is the very reason, actors and Directors do what they do, to connect with the audience. She shared how she is embarking on writing a new play on motherhood with ‘’feminist values’’, for a mainstream audience. When the audience can understand, in that sense the film was successfully able to convey the message to the audience. Amitabh Reza interestingly shared how he did not like the film, he felt ‘’cinema is a representation of Art and should entertain people, he shared that he thought it had a ‘’melodramatic structure’’, where the main prograganist is consistently struggling. Shameem Akhter, (Special Guest, Film Director) who watched all the films for both days, in response, highlighted that the mundanity of the household chores was emphasized in an excellent manner, this is the reality for women, which was especially felt during strict lockdown. It may have been boring to watch, what about for the women who are trapped in this cycle? Amitabh Reza recalled his late father’s patriarchal embodiment, which he always disliked compared with those Bangladeshi Men who migrated to the West and had a more liberal and equal attitude towards domestic tasks.
The event concluded with Khushi Kabir, Sara Zaker, Amitabh Reza and SamaBhav Film Festival Pioneer from India, Harish Sadani.



