The Western media buzz has basically moved on beyond this topic, but the relevance for understanding future leaders of the Western world has not.
It is not as scary that Trump can make these kinds of outrageous statements inappropriate for virtually anyone, let alone a candidate for the presidency of the United States -- it is that there are significant numbers of Americans who support those ideas. It is clear to me that this is not the America I came to 35 years ago.
Let us think about why Donald Trump is okay with Sadiq Khan, the newly-elected Mayor of London, and a Muslim, visiting the US even after he (Trump) made the call for banning all Muslims from entering the country.
The answer is quite simple, actually: Mr Khan demonstrably poses no security, and certainly no terroristic, threat. He has proven to all, whether they like it or not, that he is electable to public office with a popular vote in a highly reputable city in the Western world.
As a matter of fact, the list of exceptions of Muslims allowed to visit the US, should Trump have his way, is likely to grow. And if the criteria applied are objective, it is going to be a very, very long list. Like Sadiq Khan, an overwhelming majority of Muslims, in the US and elsewhere, demonstrably pose no security or terrorist threat.
One does not have to be elected as the mayor of a large city in the Western world to earn that right; there are several other ways that the same proof of not being a threat can be met.
Not all of them involve being named in a media item, or being in the public eye, for their accomplishments. For example, if you visit virtually any hospital, or higher educational institution, or research organisation, or international organisation, or governmental offices, and the like, in the US, you are almost guaranteed to see Muslims working there in very respectable positions.
The list of exceptions of Muslims allowed to visit the US, should Trump have his way, is likely to grow. And if the criteria applied are objective, it is going to be a very, very long list
These are professionals dedicated to their work. They are typically very highly educated, highly skilled, contributing citizens who pay their taxes on time and have no criminal records.
Of course, you have the larger diasporas and ethnic enclaves as well, comprised of people of various occupational engagements. They, like the professionals, have made, and are making, significant contributions, particularly the second generation and onwards. For all of these Muslims, the biggest concern is balancing work and family life and how to ensure a bright future for the next generation. In other words, these are indeed the ideal American citizens whose focus is the creation of the good society.
They represent the profile that is upheld and sought in a society that seeks peace, stability, and homeostasis. No sane politician would ever want to rid the country of all of these people.
Imagine the tremendous loss to society if there was a mass exodus of all Muslims from the US. I dare say, it will set the country back a couple of centuries with the brain drain, the loss of scientists, doctors, professors, businessmen, and many others who silently and passionately contribute towards the good of the society on a daily basis, year in and year out.
Donald Trump would tell you that his proposition is geared towards ensuring greater security for the US. And given recent global events, he does not have a hard time convincing a certain category of people, particularly those who have faced economic hardship (largely attributed to company manufacturing operations moving offshore, and, ironically, that is also something that Trump himself is guilty of doing).
Ensuring greater security is not the debate; all of us, everywhere in the entire world, seek it. It is the strategy by which we seek to achieve it that posits the solution or the enhancement of the problem.
Trump is not bothered about a workable strategy, and is not going to spend long hours explaining to the masses the practical ways of ensuring greater security (I am also not sure he knows much about the practical ways).
In his crazed fervour to occupy the White House, he chose the simple path -- scapegoating and pointing fingers at an entire group, perhaps knowing fully well that, if he ever makes it, his campaign promises will fall through (like it does for most candidates) and not much will transpire in terms of either banning Muslims or building walls to keep Mexicans out. But, at that point, it will not matter to him. He would have what he sought.
Dr Ansar Ahmed is an Effectiveness Management Consultant, currently employed by Booz Allen Hamilton and working with the US Department of Defense educational activity projects in Washington, DC.



