Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

OP-ED: The lockdown dilemma

On top of everything else, the coronavirus has confronted us with a glimpse of our own mortality

Update : 24 May 2020, 01:04 PM

Recently I have found myself waking up at the crack of dawn to a crescendo of birdsong building throughout the morning before receding into a gentle chatter. The accidental chorus of chirping has replaced the cacophony of the cars and buses. 

Living in London, I can’t say that I am missing the latter. Even the sky looks bluer (maybe wishful thinking) and the air just a bit cleaner. 

This idyllic scenario would almost be Disneyesque if the reason for the soundtrack of my day was not Covid-19.

Scouring the internet for information on the coronavirus and living with a sense of fear has become part of daily life. In his speech to the nation on May 10, UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson touched on the fact that: "There are millions of people who are both fearful of this terrible disease, and at the same time also fearful of what this long period of enforced inactivity will do to their livelihoods and their mental and physical well-being. To their futures and the futures of their children."

I do not always see eye to eye with our PM, but on this I can agree. 

There is also the fear of not knowing if the next casualty will be a family member, relative, friend, acquaintance or neighbour. 

On top of everything else, the coronavirus has confronted us with a glimpse of our own mortality.

We have in our household unintentionally developed a somewhat morbid ritual in the evenings of reading aloud the statistics of the day. Total Coronavirus cases -- 5,112,326, total deaths -- 330,282, total recovered -- 2,039,291, UK cases -- 248,293, UK deaths -- 35,704, Bangladesh cases -- 28,511, Bangladesh deaths -- 408. The list goes on.

To date, the US, Russia and Brazil have the greatest number of confirmed cases, followed by the UK, Spain and Italy. But for many countries around the world, balancing the health of its citizens with the health of the economy, has led to the lifting of restrictions albeit in phases.

According to the Financial Times, KK Cheng, professor of Public Health at the University of Birmingham stated that: "Governments have to balance between health, wealth and public acceptance ... But if you open up too early, your livelihoods will be gone, the health service will be overrun and there will be no economic activities."

There is a concerted effort to try and create a vaccine to tackle the virus, but waiting for it before opening up the economy is not a viable option for most countries. 

After nine weeks of a stringent lockdown, Italy opened its factories and parks earlier in May. This has been followed by the re-opening of restaurants, bars, cafes, hairdressers and shops provided that social distancing is enforced. It also requires everyone to wear masks in indoor public spaces.  

People are now permitted to visit relatives though this has prompted mixed emotions with some people saying that the joy of seeing family members was tempered by the fear of inadvertently infecting their elderly parents or relatives. 

Whether we like it or not Covid-19 may affect how we interact with others be it family or friends, for the foreseeable future.

Similarly, Spain has begun lifting its bans but is adhering to a four phase system allowing different regions to implement the policies at varying speeds. Most places are now letting restaurants and bars open at half capacity with people allowed to only eat or drink on terraces and outside spaces to try and maintain social distancing. 

According to a statement by the government: "Masks will be obligatory on public transport -- as they already are -- but also in enclosed spaces and on the streets if the minimum safety distance of two metres can’t be observed."

Days after relaxing lockdown in Germany, there was an increase in the number of infections reported. This was not helped by the fact that in cities across the country such as Frankfurt, Munich, Stuttgart and Berlin, thousands of people including right-wing groups and conspiracy theorists gathered in protest of the lockdown. 

Following the spike in numbers Chancellor Angela Merkel imposed an "emergency brake" whereby local authorities would have to reinstate restrictions if there were more than 50 cases per 100,000 people.

Following suit some middle and low income nations have decided to lift restrictions despite the number of deaths still being on the rise, such as India, Indonesia, Brazil, Mexico, Russia and Bangladesh. 

In most of these countries the bulk of the workforce are small traders and daily wage earners. The lockdown has hit them particularly hard given that they have no means of income bar their daily wages. Death by hunger weighs far more heavily than from the virus.

After a strict lockdown in India, imposed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the number of people who have lost their jobs and livelihoods is over 120 million. Easing the lockdown has unsurprisingly been approved by the business community. It also begs the question whether imposing a lockdown in densely populated areas or slums where social distancing is not an option, is useful or effective.

Similarly, in Bangladesh, factories and markets are now open. With the holy month of Ramadan coming to an end and Eid-ul-Fitr almost upon us, hotels and restaurants have been allowed to serve iftar as a takeaway. Some retail shops have also reopened to its customers. 

Despite the total number of reported coronavirus cases being relatively low given its population of 170 million, there is the possibility that this is just the tip of the iceberg.

The fear across the globe is that easing lockdown may create a second wave of infections. What is apparent is that there is no "one size fits all" solution to how quickly or how extensively lockdown should be lifted.

The UK has also relaxed some lockdown restrictions, but with policy guidelines somewhat vague and open to individual interpretation, I fear that once again, birds will have to raise their voices just that much more to be heard over the din of London traffic.


Top Brokers