Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Obama’s parting gift

Update : 25 Dec 2016, 07:29 PM

The US made history by abstaining from Friday’s voting on the UN Security Council resolution condemning Israel for creating Jewish settlements in the West Bank, and asking it to stop the settlements.

The Security Council passed the resolution 14-0, with US abstention. The almost unanimous resolution may not actually deter Israel from continuing on with the settlements as such resolutions affecting Israel would be mostly unenforceable, but its significance is immense.

This is the first time in the last four decades that the US has not vetoed a UN resolution against ally Israel. In all previous cases where the UN body has attempted to pass any resolution against Israel, this has been routinely vetoed by the US, but not this time.

Some say this US abstention is the last official rebuke that the Obama administration could hurl at Israel before Obama leaves office on January 20. While the world may cheer, this has dismayed not only Israel but most Republicans and especially President-elect Donald Trump.

In fact, the president-elect made an all-out effort to stop the Security Council voting by calling upon President Obama to use veto power, and requesting the Egyptian president to seek postponement of the resolution since Egypt was the sponsor.

But the voting went on, because four other non-permanent members of the council -- Malaysia, New Zealand, Senegal and Venezuela -- put it on vote the next day.

The US administration under President Obama has been steadfastly asking Israel to stop building settlements in the West Bank that had been constantly increasing since 1968 after the bank’s Israeli occupation.

The objectives of the settlement initiated by Israel were to secure a Jewish majority in the strategic regions of the West Bank. There are now over 400,000 Jewish settlers spread in 150 or so settlements in the West Bank, and another 200,000 settlers in Jerusalem.

The US had not officially approved or disapproved the settlements, but, in discussion with Israel, past and present US presidents had urged upon Israel to stop these advancements, calling them impediments to a peaceful negotiation between Palestine and Israel (the international community and the Arab countries had severely criticised these settlements, calling them illegal).

From time to time, under different presidents, the topic has surfaced as a sticking point in arriving at a peaceful resolution between the two adversaries, but no US administration has ever directly twisted Israel’s arm to stop the settlement.

Meanwhile, Israel continued to build these settlements despite international concerns.

The latest spat between the US and Israel on the settlement issue came from Israel allowing a new settlement, one of a string of housing complexes that threaten to bisect the West Bank. The US had strongly urged Israel not to proceed with this, but Israeli authorities bent under pressure from the settlers who had to be removed from an illegal settlement nearby.

The Obama administration was particularly upset because Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu had not indicated approval of the new settlement when he visited Israel in September this year a few weeks before this particular Israeli decision. It was particularly upsetting for Obama as the US and Israel had signed a lucrative military package earlier.

A UN resolution asking Israel to stop the West Bank settlements has been long overdue.

The US’s facilitation of the passing of this resolution through abstention also shows not only the Obama administration’s exasperation with Israel, but it is also an acknowledgment of Israel’s critics in the US who seriously disapprove of the country’s policies to expand its territories

It did not happen because all previous US administrations in the past, Democratic or Republican, did not want to openly chastise its staunch ally in the Middle East.

As much as the previous administrations promoted dialogue for peace between Israel and Palestine, they also knew the powerful political support Israel had created in the US.

Any public display of displeasure with Israel on any issue could be costly in the domestic politics of the country where Israel has cultivated powerful and wealthy friends. Therefore, this public spat with Israel by the outgoing US administration is naturally not being viewed well by the Republicans.

Ironically, the president-elect, who had once declared during his campaign that he would be neutral in the Israel-Palestine relationship, had been the most critical of this UN resolution, adding that things will be very different for the UN after he takes office.

The sentiment expressed by the president-elect on the UN resolution captures only a glimpse of the changes to come on the Israel-Palestinian issue, and, for that matter, the entire Middle East, after President Obama leaves office. Donald Trump has already nominated someone as US ambassador to Israel who is an open advocate of Israeli settlement in the West Bank. The president-elect has also made known his intentions to move the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, a city severely contested by the Palestinian Authority for its own seat of government.

In fact, the status of Jerusalem has been the thorniest issue in any peace negotiations between the two rivals. Should Donald Trump follow through with his assurance to Israel, this alone would seriously jeopardise negotiations between Israel and Palestinian Authority.

US abstention in the Security Council voting may prompt a few cheers from the Palestinians and other countries, however ineffective the resolution may be. But, not only does it show the Obama administration’s exasperation with Israel, it is also an acknowledgment of Israel’s critics in the US who seriously disapprove of the country’s policies to expand its territories by browbeating its weaker neighbour.

There are hundreds of organisations in the US who disapprove of this policy and continue to mobilise public opinion against the settlements. In the past, such protests did not get a chance to gather international support, but last Friday they did.

Unfortunately, this may be the last time that the US would ever show such official disapproval of Israel in an international forum. The next administration has already shown the extra mile it would go in support of Israel, be it in the expansion of the settlements or helping Israel move its capital.

It is possible that with a more overtly-friendly ally in the White House and a Republican Congress come January 20, 2017, Israel will feel free to expand its hold over the West Bank, and try to fulfill its goal of making Jerusalem its capital.

But in helping Israel at its bidding will only further jeopardise US relations with the Middle East and question its role as an honest broker in the elusive peace process in that region.

Ziauddin Choudhury has worked in the higher civil service of Bangladesh early in his career, and later for the World Bank in the USA.

Top Brokers