Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Leave it to the market

Update : 20 Aug 2017, 12:24 AM
It’s entirely true that markets aren’t perfect, sometimes they fail, often enough they do not include all which must usefully be included. However, the important thing to understand about markets is that they’re often very useful, even if imperfect. This insight aids us in illuminating two problems mentioned recently in this newspaper. The first is the problem, explained by Mushfique Wadud, whereby those with advanced degrees are taking peon level jobs – peon not being a word I’d be able to use in this context in most varieties of English. What is meant is the sort of job that just requires some live human being to turn up and do, not those who have been expensively educated. And I agree, given the way I make my own living, that low paid journalists are one of the Terrors of the Ages – this must definitely be fixed. The analysis is that the universities are not turning out the skills required by industry and also that industry is not taking note of the skills, abilities, and training of those coming out of the colleges. The correct way to consider this is that this is a market working rather well. People do pay well for those things they value. If graduates, even with advanced degrees, are not being paid well then this is evidence that those skills, that training, is not thought to be of value. And the thing about value is that it is always in the eye of the beholder. It is not that something ought to be valuable, it is when a human being looks at it and says yes it is or no it’s not.
The thing about value is that it is always in the eye of the beholder. It is not that something ought to be valuable, it is when a human being looks at it and says yes it is or no it’s not
Thus we can indeed say that a Masters degree in, say, 18th century Bengali poetry should be valuable, but whether it is or not is determined by whether someone will pay for it. The same is true of gender studies or a PhD in garment making machinery design. And we tend to think we know how those valuations will play out in the Bangladesh of today. If we thus find ourselves in that place where advanced graduates are doing those peon jobs then that is not market failure, that is market information – the value employers place upon those advanced degrees is low. There is a counter argument which is that in general rich countries have more graduates than poor, also that there is a graduate premium, graduates earn more than non-graduates. These are both true but still there are variations here. In my native UK, an arts degree for a man reduces his lifetime income, that is the years not earning plus the costs of the degree are greater than the higher income achieved. Science degrees for men and women still produce higher lifetime earnings overall. Again, this is the market telling us what it is that people value. Value in that economic sense of course, as it’s still entirely possible to gain great personal and intellectual value from studying 18th century poets. Over in the banking system, we’ve Mr Ibrahim and Choudhury making noises about how many private sector banks there are, quite possibly too many. As we’ve noted before, we most definitely want to have regulation of the banking sector and system. Letting the criminals into where all the money is just doesn’t work out as a good idea. However, that’s an argument over who we allow to be a banker and how we allow them to do banking. It isn’t, as the gentlemen are extending it to, a reasonable argument about how many we allow to try their hand at being a banker. That’s something we can and should leave to the market itself. If there are too many bankers chasing what limited useful business there is then those who are worse at banking will be losing money. For a company, or an investor, losing money is the universe’s signal that perhaps consideration should be given to going and doing something else. Good profits are that opposite signal that you should carry on as now. We can rely upon those signals, in a manner that planning does not manage, to regulate the number of people undertaking a trade or line of business. If there are too many then those losing money will exit the business – in the case of banking it tends to be shrinking a balance sheet rather than complete expiry but we get to the same effect. And, of course, if we start limiting the number of licences guess who will be lobbying for a restrictive number of licences? Quite, those who already have one. The results of that we can see in the New York City taxi market. For decades, there was a restriction upon how many medallions – a licence to operate a cab – could be issued. So much so that the value of the licence alone, unattached to a car or a driver, reached $1 million. Then came Uber, which provides rides without needing the medallion, the price of the licence plummets. Again, simple observation of the market shows us that more medallions should have been issued, there is no logic to it costing $1 million to drive a taxi. When things get this extreme, markets also solve such problems, as with Uber. That value of the medallion economists call an economic rent. Someone getting something for not doing anything other than just having the right little piece of paper, the right little privilege. The same would be true of limiting the number of banking licences, the restriction would produce a profit for those who already have them as they would be free from the threat of competition from new entrants. Yes, we do indeed need to limit who becomes a banker, even how they do banking, but we don’t want to limit how many who meet the criteria do so. As I say, markets aren’t perfect but they are useful. We can say much the same about regulation and government of course. Our usual rule of thumb being let’s use markets where we can then turn to that regulation and government – only where we must.  Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.
Top Brokers