Dr Kamal Hossain yesterday critcised the election commission for failing to create an atmosphere ensuring the participation of all in the January 5 general elections, which resulted in more than half the members of the 10th parliament getting elected unopposed.
The respected jurist made the remark when he appeared as an amicus curiae (friend of the court) in the High Court Division yesterday in connection with a writ petition challenging the validity of section 19 of the Representation of the People Order (RPO).
“People did not find any confidence in the elections... because free and fair elections were not possible under the ruling government. But what could the election commission do? They could have taken legal opinion as they had the opportunity to ask the Supreme Court for advice. This is what the people are saying, this is what the ruling party is saying and this is the judgment of former chief justice ABM Khairul Haque,” said Dr Kamal, giving his opinion before the bench of Justice Mirza Hussain Haider and Justice Khurshid Alam Sarkar.
Jatiya Party leader Khandker Abdus Salam filed the writ on December 17 last year challenging the validity of the RPO section that allows the EC to declare a lone candidate in an election the winner, without holding a ballot.
Dr Kamal, however, did not clearly say whether the provision for uncontested winners was unconstitutional or not. The High Court had earlier sought his opinion on the validity of the provision.
Dr Kamal, one of the framers of the country’s constitution, said the EC faced a dilemma ahead of the 2014 polls, but in the end, it went along with the ruling party, keeping 80 percent of the electorate out.
He added that the Election Commission made a mistake, but it still had a chance to make amends as per the constitution.
“The Election Commission should not work like a post office _issuing a circular and then issuing another gazette notification. Nor should the commission work as a branch of the government’s press office,” Dr Kamal said, adding that the EC was not the private property of any political party.
Making a cricket reference, the leading lawyer said before the start of a match, the umpires go out to inspect the field with the representatives of both teams.
“If one side says the pitch is fine, but the other says it is not, the umpires will take a decision based on good faith. The Election Commission should play the role of an umpire. National elections are like the world cup, and it is necessary to earn everyone’s confidence,” he said.
The lawyer also said more than 80 percent of the people in this country believed that the incumbent EC would not be remembered in history like its predecessor, which conducted the 9th parliamentary polls in December 2008.
“How many people voted and how many (MPs) got elected uncontested is a simple but a serious matter,” Dr Kamal said, adding, “Our politics is sharply divided. If one says day, then the other will say night. But the voters are the larger group. So, the EC should have thought about the voters _ 70 percent of whom were deprived of their voting rights.”
Defending himself for getting elected uncontested twice _ in 1970 and 1973 _ Dr Kamal said those elections were historical, and it would be inappropriate to compare them to the January5 polls.
After Dr Kamal’s argument, Badiul Alam Majumdar, secretary of SUJAN, a citizen’s group promoting good governance, read out a paper explaining the different articles of the Bangladesh’s constitution and other countries, citing examples of participatory elections and the election commission’s role for holding free, fair and credible polls.
Arguments regarding the writ will resume today.



