Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

NBR revises outstanding SIM replacement tax

Update : 21 Apr 2014, 09:12 PM

The National Board of Revenue has once again finalised a report which says four mobile phone operators will now have to pay Tk2,464.88 crore, instead of Tk3,010 crore claimed earlier, as tax for SIM resale.

This time the NBR has got approval of the Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC) but none of the four operators – Grameenphone, Banglalink, Robi and Airtel – gave consent on the report terming it “unilateral and unacceptable.”

The operators say they did not resell the subscriber identification modules (SIMs), rather replaced them, so no tax would be applicable.

The telecomm regulator signed the report with some reservations, and if its argument proved to be true, the claimed figure will come down to Tk520.60 crore, sources said.

According to the NBR’s latest claim, Grameenphone’s tax outstanding is Tk1,305.52 crore. It was Tk1,562 crore in the NBR’s final report published last December. Banglalink’s outstanding comes down to Tk566.98 crore from Tk762 crore, Robi has to pay Tk558.92 crore instead of Tk647 crore while Airtel Tk33.46 crore from Tk39 crore mentioned in the previous report.

But if the NBR takes the regulator’s argument, these amounts would come down for Grameenphone to Tk331.88 core, Banglalink Tk65.79 core, Robi Tk121.69 crore and Airtel Tk1.24 crore only.

The NBR has been demanding the amount of tax from the four companies since early 2012. After analysing the documents, it first demanded Tk3,062 crore. Of the amounts, Grameenphone was supposed to pay Tk1,562 crore, Banglalink Tk762 crore, Robi Tk647 crore and Airtel Tk39 crore.

According to the latest report, 79% of the documents show that the SIM cards were resold to different subscribers. SIM resale to a different owner is not allowed by the rule.

The review committee – comprising representatives from the BTRC and the four operators – says the operators have dodged tax through selling old SIMs to new clients. Currently, the companies pay Tk300 tax against the sale of a SIM card.

The NBR’s SIM Card Replacement Review Committee (SCRRC) prepared the final report in December last year after scrutinising the SAF, SIM Registration Form (SRF) and Undertaking Form (UTF) of the operators submitted between August 2010 and December 2011. At that time, SIM tax was Tk800.

The Dhaka Tribune obtained a copy of the revised report.

The NBR came up with the findings after scrutinising the SIM replacement data supplied by the operators – 1,400 samples of Grameenphone; 1,200 of Banglalink; 1,200 of Robi and Airtel’s 1,097 samples.

“Random sampling is never applicable for taxation anywhere in the world,” a senior executive of a mobile operator told the Dhaka Tribune about the report seeking anonymity.

The Association of Mobile Telecom Operators of Bangladesh (Amtob) terms the report very confusing. “Foreign investors want a respectable solution and our government is cordial about the issue,” TIM Nurul Kabir, secretary general of Amtob, told the Dhaka Tribune yesterday.

In December last year, the Amtob sent a letter to the NBR, the BTRC and the Telecommunications Ministry seeking a solution saying that the revenue authorities had used a new process for re-verification of the SIM information.

The NBR report says nearly 79% of the submitted documents did not match with the original Subscriber Application Forms (SAF).

Before the 3G auction, a report of the tripartite committee labelled a few of the documents to be “problematic.”

The NBR prepared terms of reference (TOR) last year. It was approved by the Finance Ministry before the auction to quantify the resold SIMs, said Vivek Sood, chief executive officer of Grameenphone. But the NBR unilaterally revised the TOR after the operators had participated in the 3G auction which is “not acceptable,” he said while speaking at the company’s year-end financial disclosure recently.

He hoped that the NBR chairman would review the matter and find a solution.

Meanwhile, the NBR has found inconsistencies in the provided information, but the telecom regulator claims that there is no inconsistency.

According to the SCRRC report, Grameenphone’s 94.79% of the provided information were inconsistent. This is the highest among the operators, followed by Banglalink’s 94.83%, Robi’s 93.42% and Airtel’s 29.81%.

Grameenphone failed to provide any Call Details Record (CDR) data before 2010, so the committee could not cross-check the data for the period, says the report.

It also mentions that Banglalink provided incomplete data of a specific field while Airtel’s CDR failed to provide the incoming call records, subscribers’ handset IMIE numbers and some system logs before the committee. 

Top Brokers