Political leaders and analysts say no matter who comes next to power in India, the leadership in New Delhi will maintain good relationship with Dhaka for its own interests.
“If India feels that it will have an unpleasant relationship with Bangladesh, it will affect New Delhi more than Dhaka,” prime minister’s Economic Adviser Mashiur Rahman told the Dhaka Tribune recently.
Asked what New Delhi’s policy would be if Narendra Modi became the Indian premier or any non-Congress coalition selected another person, he said: “I am not a soothsayer. We knew the BJP leadership when it formed the government last time, but we have less interaction with the current leadership.
“It will be a very risky policy for India.”
“From previous experiences, I think India will not resist Bangladesh from doing all the work here – no new crisis will be created and it will be a neutral relationship; but, it will be difficult to find new areas of opportunity or cooperation.”
About Modi’s recent remarks on getting rid of so-called illegal Bangladeshi immigrants in India, Mashiur said: “It will be a very risky policy for India.”
Pushing or sending back Bangalee Muslims in the name of getting rid of illegal immigrants would cause more harm to New Delhi than Dhaka, he said.
“Bangladesh has the ability to contain any crisis but India does not. Muslims in India will not come to Bangladesh and they will resist any such move. That will lead to a riot in the country [India],” he expressed fear.
If there is any repercussion of the Indian policy here, Hindus might leave Bangladesh for India and thus create a fresh problem for them, Mashiur said.
“In addition, neither of the Bangladesh and Indian governments certifies that there are illegal migrants from Bangladesh. So, how will you identify which group has come from Bangladesh and which has not?
“The BJP and Modi want to achieve economic prosperity and any such move will not help that cause. Their [India’s] international image as a secular country will also be damaged,” said the adviser.
India has many outstanding issues with China and Pakistan and has strained relationships with other neighbouring countries including Bangladesh, he said.
Mashiur, however, said under the central government system in India, it would never be a one-man show. Various stakeholders, including the voices of different states, must be taken into account before making any decision.
Humayun Kabir, former ambassador to the US and director general of the South Asia Desk at the Foreign Ministry, told the Dhaka Tribune that the Modi administration might bring a couple of changes.
Citing the electoral manifesto of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), he said it wanted to curb corruption and accelerate development in the backdrop of the poor economic performance over the last couple of years.
They wanted internal stability regardless of the criticisms that Modi or the BJP would fuel communalism.
“I think that is unlikely. Social and political tensions will really sap the energy of the government and may also deter the possibility of higher economic growth,” Humayun said.
“My feeling is that regardless of what we hear from the campaign trail, if Modi wants to ensure good governance and higher economic performance, then stable internal environment and improved regional environment is a must,” he said.
The former diplomat feels that bringing up the issue of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants was just a strategy to attract votes.
“We cannot ignore the fact that the BJP is trying to consolidate Hindu votes and for that it needed to find a scapegoat,” he said.
The BJP was weak in West Bengal and other states along the border of Bangladesh, and it had been trying to make an inroad into the politics of these states, he added.
“Whatever India got over the last five years is definitely a net gain, especially in terms of security, economic cooperation and connectivity...Why should any government in India change this positive course?
“We [Bangladesh] must develop a bipartisan approach to deal with India. In India, bipartisanism exists in the relationship with neighbours.
"It is extremely important that we [also] develop a bipartisan approach with regards to our relationship with India and other major countries,” Humayun said.
Meanwhile, Commerce Minister Tofail Ahmed has warned that playing the “infiltration card” in election campaign will negatively impact Dhaka-Delhi relationships.
Asked about Modi’s statement that all “illegal Bangladeshi migrants” in India should pack and leave on May 16 – the result day of the Indian polls, Tofail recently told the Dhaka Tribune over phone: “Any hasty step made by the new government [in India] will hit bilateral ties.”
Tofail also said there were “no illegal immigrants from Bangladesh in India.”
In an interview with Indian TV channel Times Now last week, Tofail said: “I do not believe that in the name of illegal immigrants, the settlers living in India will be pushed back or sent back...If [any such step] is taken, the relationship between the two countries will be jeopardised.”
Indian media reported last Tuesday that Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina had expressed concerns over the remarks made by Modi.
Indian daily The Economic Times published a report that said “a person familiar with the matter” from Dhaka informed the newspaper that in a private meeting on Monday morning Hasina told her close aides that Modi’s comments were “unnecessary and unwarranted.”
The prime minister told her aides that such statements could spoil relations between the future Indian government and Bangladeshi citizens, the newspaper reported.
Meanwhile, the BJP has endorsed Modi’s stance against alleged Bangladeshi infiltrators as “justified and legitimate.”
An article, written by leader of the opposition Arun Jaitley and posted on the BJP website, said: “It is not only the BJP’s stand that infiltration must be stopped and the infiltrators must be sent back. The Supreme Court described it as a silent invasion of India.”
The BJP has been playing the “infiltration card” to lure voters in their favour from the beginning of its election campaign.
Modi in his election campaign said several times that he would get rid of the “Bangladeshi infiltrators” if he came to power.



