Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

BTRC lying to government about tariff cut proposal

Update : 21 May 2014, 09:38 PM

The telecom regulator has reportedly provided false information to the government about the volume of legal international incoming calls, in an attempt to show that a proposed reduction of termination rate would not affect government income from the sector.

Termination rate is when one telecom operator charges another for terminating calls on its network.

Although a previous BTRC estimation, prepared seven months ago when the reduction was first proposed, had showed that the cuts would cost around Tk1,073 crore worth of losses, a fresh proposal by the watchdog claimed that the government will earn an additional Tk162 crore if the change is implemented.

The Dhaka Tribune has obtained both the recommendations by the Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC).

Seeking anonymity, several BTRC senior executives admitted to the Dhaka Tribune that they fabricated only one number which changed the whole scenario; however, the telecom watchdog refused to give any official comment on the issue.

This correspondent waited two hours at the BTRC chairman’s office on Tuesday for his comments and also tried yesterday, but there was no response.

However, more than a dozen senior officials confirmed to the Dhaka Tribune that there was no truth in the claims of potential government profit, adding that they manipulated the numbers as per their boss’ demand.

The false estimations were reportedly prepared to favour the cause of international gateway (IGW) operators.

According to the fresh proposal, the telecom watchdog claimed that the existing daily 3.5 crore minutes of incoming international calls volume will cross 9 crore minutes if the termination rate is halved from the existing 3 US cents ($0.03) per minute.

The Telecom Ministry is now scrutinising the proposal after receiving it from the BTRC last week, and it might be forwarded to the Finance ministry for approval today.

The latest move comes only months after the government also cut the annual licence fee in half for the IGW operators.

Both proposals from the BTRC claimed that the government is now annually earning around Tk1,851.1 crore from this sector, with a daily average of 3.5 crore minutes of incoming calls.

Although the regulator previously claimed that the government would be able to earn only Tk777.99 crore every year if the rate was reduced to 1.5 US cents per minute, it is now claiming that the earning will be Tk2,012.72 crore as the call volume has increased.

The regulator’s claim of an average 3.5 crore minutes of daily calls was also found to be false, as BTRC figures show that the daily call volume has not gone below four crore minutes in any month over the past year.

The Dhaka Tribune also found that the current volume of daily incoming international calls is six crore minutes, while the average for the past year was 5.04 crore minutes.

BTRC statistics showed that during February, total incoming calls were 153.7 crore minute and the daily average was 5.5 crore minutes. In March it was 5.9 crore minutes per day and in April it was 5.7 crore minutes every day on an average.

There were also some days when call termination had reached 12 crore minutes in a single day.

“As the current call termination volume is around six crore minutes, there is no need to reduce the rate,” a former senior officer of the BTRC, who was involved with the process for a long time, told the Dhaka Tribune.

He estimated that if call volume increased up to 9 crore minutes after the termination rate was cut in half, the government would have to suffer losses worth hundreds of crore of taka.

The Telecom Ministry has also reportedly raised questions about the issue, before passing it forward to the Finance Ministry for approval.

BTRC’s recommendation also claimed that neighbouring countries’ call termination rate is much lower than Bangladesh, which sources said is also a lie.

The VoIP Service Providers Association (VSPA) said the call termination rates in neighbouring countries are three to eight times higher than Bangladesh.

“The per minute international call termination rate in Sri Lanka is 9 US cents, 9.5 cents in Nepal, 8.8 cents in Pakistan and 25 cents in Maldives, which is the highest,” said VSPA Convener Rabiul Karim.

Only the Indian termination rate is lower than in Bangladesh, but their termination pattern is different than Bangladesh’s, sources said.

Apart from its proposal for reducing the termination rate, the BTRC also recommended changing the revenue sharing structure, proposing a reduction of the government’s share from the existing 51.75% to 40%, as well as increasing shares for the IGWs and other operators.

Legal specialists, however, said the government cannot arbitrarily change the structure as the rate was fixed by an open auction.

“The revenue sharing structure had been fixed through a public auction in 2008 and the BTRC cannot change it,” said Barrister Aneek R Haque, a Supreme Court lawyer.

Telecommunication Infrastructure Operators of Bangladesh (TOIB), a platform of the IGW operators, however wants to see strong monitoring over illegal call terminations.

“We know that the overall situation will not improve even after the rate is cut. Rather, the BTRC should become more worried about the illegal call terminations and initiate more policing on it,” Mir Nasir Hossain, president of the TOIB told the Dhaka Tribune. 

Top Brokers