Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Buet experts differ with RMG compliance groups

Update : 03 Jun 2014, 09:41 PM

Experts of Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology and compliance oversight groups, Alliance and Accord, have differed over the standards of load of the buildings housing the readymade garment factories.

A team of civil engineers from Buet inspected 200 buildings accommodating 252 factories between October 2013 and January 2014 and suggested no abandonment of the buildings while the oversight groups detected many buildings for ‘poor safety standards’.

Up to June 3, Department of Inspection for Factories and Establishment closed down 15 factories housed in five buildings, its inspector general told Syed Ahmed the Dhaka Tribune.

According to the standards set by Accord, an alliance of European buyers, and Alliance, the group of North American importers, the maximum load for brick-made buildings in Bangladesh is 1,800 PSI (per square inch) and 2,100 PSI for stone stuffed buildings.

But Buet team set 2,100 PSI and 2,400 PSI for brick-made buildings and stone stuffed buildings respectively.

If the Accord-Alliance standards are implemented, the experts fear at least 30% factories of the US $30 billion industry would be shut.

Today, the Buet team members will meet the Accord-Alliance technicians to set the standards according to which they would suggest building conditions to ensure safety standards for the garment industry.

“The Buet team has huge expertise on the building patterns in Bangladesh. They have set the standards of 2,100 PSI and 2,400 PSI for brick and stone stuffed factory buildings. Buet has not suggested any closure, recommending minor structural changes and overhaul of electrical wiring,” Syed Ahmed told the Dhaka Tribune.

He said the Alliance-Accord standards were ‘not acceptable’, referring that their standards, if applied, would spell disaster for the country’s readymade garment industry.

Concerns over factory buildings constructed

The Alliance-Accord Group is obstinate on changing its stance on standards of buildings constructed before 2005, a Buet professor told the Dhaka Tribune, referring that they would accept the Buet standards for factories built after 2005.

“About 90% of the buildings housing garment factories were built before 2005; so applying their standards would spell disaster for the industry,” he said.

Syed Ahmed said: “There is a little change in the construction pattern of buildings in Bangladesh. So, the debate over standards associating the buildings constructed before and after 2005 is illogical.”

Buet report highlights

Out of the total 252 factories inspected, the Buet experts detected some minor structural problems in 25 factories that can be renovated within at best six weeks. The team identified some minor difficulties such as damping walls, leaking of water, constructing storehouses in 30 factories worthy of being repaired with renovation.

But almost all of the factories beset with fire and electrical safety deficits such as narrow fire door and approach road for the fire fighters, electrical load management problems, haphazard electrical wiring and flaws in the wiring joints and others, which can result in short circuit.

According to the figures of fire service and civil defence wing of the Home Ministry, over 80% of the fire incidents are caused by electrical short circuits.

Top Brokers