The government has decided to request the Bangladesh Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, BCSIR, to examine whether the recently-introduced controversial Bt brinjal has any adverse health impact.
The move comes after a UK importer threatened that the European Union would stop vegetable imports if any such genetically-modified eggplant is detected in a consignment.
An inter-ministry meeting on December 31 last year discussed the possible implications of the government nod and decided to assign the BCSIR to research on the effects of the crop on human health.
Bangladesh is the first country in South Asia to approve the GM brinjal – containing a gene that deters insects from diseases – against the global concerns that such eggplant would be toxic for human health and change the local biodiversity.
Except for 29 states, the authorities across the globe have been examining for decades the probable effects of GM organisms on human health and environment.
The national bio-safety committee under the Environment Ministry on October 31 approved commercial cultivation of four varieties of Bt brinjal in Bangladesh.
Anti-GMO campaigners allege that the move was made without conducting proper study. They also filed writ petitions with the High Court demanding extensive study on the crop.
Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute (BARI) scientists, however, claim that the Bt brinjal would not do any harm to soil, environment or the farmers. It stresses that these varieties would protect the insects responsible for 70% losses of brinjal.
On December 4, Helena Paul of GM Freeze, a London-based importer of vegetables, emailed to the government warning it about the possibility of mixing the Bt brinjal with the vegetables exported from Bangladesh, terming the GM crop “very injurious to health.”
“Any detection of Bt brinjal in the consignment would result in the suspension of vegetables import by the European Union from Bangladesh,” said a letter of the Export Promotion Bureau of the Commerce Ministry.
The Dhaka Tribune has obtained the letter, issued on December 24 last year.
The December 31 meeting was attended by representatives from the Commerce Ministry, the EPB, Bangladesh agricultural Research Council, BARI, BCSIR’s Institute of Food Science and Technology, Plant Protection Wing of the Department of Agricultural Extension, the vegetable exporters and other stakeholders to discuss about the letter.
“According to the decision of the meeting, we have decided to task the science laboratory [BCSIR] to examine whether the Bt brinjal had consequences on human health as the matter is very controversial,” Abdur Rauf, EPB’s director (commodities), told the Dhaka Tribune.
He said the government had no plan to export Bt brinjal which was released for limited-scale cultivation.
On January 23, Agriculture Minister Matia Chowdhury handed over samplings of Bt brinjal to the farmers as the BARI scientists had certified that it caused no harm to the human health and environment – a proposition vehemently opposed by environmentalists and anti-GMO groups.
They say the government had “very little” study on Bt brinjal’s effects on the environment and its health consequences.
Monjurul Islam, an adviser to Bangladesh Vegetable and Allied Products Exporters’ Association, told the Dhaka Tribune that local brinjal was one of the regular items sent to the European markets, especially in London.
“The European Union is so strict that they can totally suspend vegetable export from Bangladesh in the case of detection of a single Bt brinjal in a consignment,” he said.
Monjurul said the vegetable exporters had not been consulted before the government cleared the way for commercial cultivation of the controversial crop.
“Very often we get complaint letters from the European Union on consignment of local brinjal with pests. Even any mistaken mixture of Bt brinjal will be catastrophic for our vegetable export,” an official of the Plant Protection Wing of the DAE said.
Commercialisation of the Bt brinjal, developed by American company Monsanto, is a highly controversial issue across the globe.
For instance, these GM crops contain a gene from soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiesnsis that protects the eggplants from insect attack through its internal toxicity.
India in 2009 tried to go for commercialisation of the Bt brinjal, it had to lift the decision upon strong public opinion.



