The negatives outweighs the positive in Bangladesh Cricket Board's decision to split the selection committee into two levels. The existing three-member selection panel will have the head coach, team manager and the cricket operations committee chairman on top of them.
BCB president Nazmul Hasan finalised the decision earlier this week and said that only the approval of the board of directors remain. It is likely to be discussed at the next meeting this month.
Previous occasions of “lack of communication” between Bangladesh coach Chandika Hathurusingha and chief selector Faruk Ahmed has been cited as the main reason for making these changes in the process of picking the Bangladesh squad ahead of a series and tournament.
Although there are many examples of coaches being included in the selection process around the cricketing world, the role of a team manager and the cricket operation chairman is rare.
But the inclusion of the head coach in the selection panel could also make a negative impact among the players who would now want to be in his good book as the coach will have the ultimate power in Bangladesh cricket.
Yet at the same time Bangladesh team have been doing pretty well under Hathurusingha's coaching in the past two years, so his inclusion may have a positive impact. The coach can now set his desired players for certain roles in which he has been looking to do for a long time.
But the inclusion of Khaled Mahmud and Akram Khan, both board directors, is being considered as the board's way of having their representation in the selection panel, which could affect its independence.
It is also unprecedented to have the team manager and board directors to be included in the selection panel.
Already, Faruk said that he may resign if these changes are made to the selection committee. In the past he has had public disagreements with the team management over selection matters. In February 2014 Mushfiqur Rahim blasted Faruk for not consulting him in selecting the Asia Cup team. In January 2015, Hathurusingha said that he prefered having legspinner Jubair Hossain in the World Cup squad while the BCB also questioned the selectors over the inclusion of Al-Amin Hossain and Nasir Hossain.
In June, Hathurusingha and Faruk had disagreement over the selection of Shuvagata Hom.
Still, according to some former players including Aminul Islam Bulbul, the new selection committee will have a negative affect in future if it includes the manager and coach.
So is this a fancy decision on the part of the BCB, when things are going well for the Tigers?



