The government could not come to any conclusive decision about the long dispute over SIM replacement tax between the National Board of Revenue (NBR) and four mobile phone operators.
The dispute over the NBR claims for tax involving hundreds of crores Taka would now go to the Prime Minister for her interference to reach a decision, officials said.
NBR claimed Grameenphone, Banglalink, Robi and Airtel replaced SIMs with old ones, but did not pay the tax applicable for this purpose.
There were two key meeting, yesterday at the Finance and Telecommunications Ministry with Law ministry, National Board of Revenue and Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission, but a a decision could not be taken about the SIM replacement tax calculation process, said an official.
“We are working on it and hopefully we can resolve the long disputed issue without wasting any time, and I think it may need one more meeting for the settlement,” M Faizur Rahaman Chowdhury told the Dhaka Tribune after the meeting.
But he could not confirm whether it need to send to the Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina’s table.
An official of the finance ministry said as it is a huge amount, the finance ministry or the finance minister would not take the risk to make a decision.
According to the NBR’s claim, four mobile phone operators have to pay a tax of about Tk2,465 crore due to SIM replacement. On the other hand, operators claim that they did not need to pay fresh tax because they had only replaced damaged or lost SIM cards for which taxes were already paid.
Earlier in 2012, the NBR had demanded for the first time Tk3,062 crore in taxes due to SIM replacement by the four operators during a period between July 2009 and December 2011. NBR later revised their claim to Tk3,010 crore.
But when the mobile operator’s raised objection about the report just before the 3G spectrum auction, NBR formed a review committee and they placed an interim a report where NBR’s claim was only Tk251 crore.
But after the 3G auction NBR again revised up their claim to Tk2,465 crore as they prepared their final report.
Mobile operators disagreed with this report and criticised the NBR’s shifting of stance.
“The procedure followed was inconsistent with the original terms of reference regarding the report prepared by the committee members,” a senior executive of a mobile operator said.
Another senior executive who was present at the second meeting held at the finance ministry said they have discussed about all the numbers and the shifting. So nothing is final at this level.
He said earlier the PM had decided some telecom issues like 2G license renewal fees, 3G spectrum fees; and now the international call termination rate reduction proposal is on the PM’s table.



