Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

BTRC may give 3 WiMax licences at 2008 price

Update : 04 Oct 2013, 08:55 PM

Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC) is allegedly maintaining no consistency in allocating spectrum, often “ignoring the economic value” of radio frequencies.

Many allege that the regulator has often charged the highest for spectrum in the past two years while allotting multi-million dollar bands sometimes absolutely free.

Abu Saeed Khan, a senior policy fellow at the Colombo-based regulatory thinktank LIRNEasia and former secretary general of the Association of Mobile and Telecom Operators of Bangladesh (Amtob), has termed the situation utterly unprofessional.

“The BTRC often ignores the economic value of radio frequencies and grants the invaluable national assets mostly on political whims. It largely imitates India’s 2G frequency scandal but has learnt no lessons from that,” Saeed told the Dhaka Tribune.

Unlike in India, the institutions to investigate and prosecute the telecom regulator’s anomalies in Bangladesh “lack the tooth and nail,” he said.

At the latest auction on September 8, the BTRC sold spectrum on 2,100 band to mobile operators for Tk1.61bn per Megahertz with additional 5% VAT. The operators have already paid 60% of the amount.

The regulator is now going to give at least two WiMax licences consisting of 20MHz spectrum on the 2,600 band which is mostly known as the LTE (long term evolution, a 4G standard for high-speed wireless data) band for Tk2.15bn, meaning the price of 1MHz LTE spectrum will stand at Tk107.5m.

ICT professionals claimed that 2,100 and 2,600 bands held technically the same power, both spectrums being a natural extension of the 3G and widely auctioned for 4G LTE.

Amtob has already expressed concern over the issue, terming the process discriminatory as the price of the WiMax licences was fixed in an auction held in 2008.

The BTRC and the government have decided to award WiMax licence to Bangladesh Internet Exchange Limited (BIEL) for its Ollo brand.

On September 15, the BTRC sent a letter signed by its Senior Assistant Director Shazeda Parvin to the BIEL, informing it about the licence awarding.

The government has also approved Mango Teleservices’ application for WiMax licence, but the telecom regulator is yet to take any initiative to that end.

According to documents, the BIEL secured fifth position in the 2008 auction, having called a price of Tk1.75bn, but soon afterwards it pulled out of the auction by withdrawing the Tk30m earnest money.

Terming this the “biggest spectrum scam” in Bangladesh, legal professionals said the same thing had happened in India in 2008 in which the Indian telecommunication ministry had caused the exchequer losses of nearly $40bn by selling licences at a price fixed back in 2001.

Indian telecommunication minister A Raja had to resign after the country’s comptroller and auditor general had detected the scam. The matter also went to the country’s High Court.

BTRC Chairman Sunil Kanti Bose on Friday told the Dhaka Tribune that the spectrum prices had been different because “we have to set prices as per government directives.”

On giving spectrum to WiMax operators at a rate of 2008 auction, he said: “The price Tk2.15bn for 20MHz was too high for the time. Charging that now would be justified.

“This will not be unlawful and this will not cause any loss to the government.” Supreme Court lawyer barrister Tanjib-ul Alam, however, said it was totally illegal.

He said: “The BIEL is not eligible for the licence unless a new auction is held.”

In a letter to the telecommunication ministry dated August 29, Amtob said: “Since the 2,600 band is widely considered as the natural upgrading for the 2,100 band, their prices cannot be so widely apart, thus it should be fixed rationally.”

In a recent interview mobile operator Banglalink’s CEO Ziad Shatara told the Dhaka Tribune that the price difference for the two spectrums was not justified.

The CEO of another mobile operator, requesting anonymity, said: “We got spectrum free in 1997, then bought it at Tk800m per Megahertz in 2008 and at Tk1.5bn in 2011. This time at the 3G auction we bought it at a rate of Tk1.61bn per Megahertz. So, why is the spectrum price for WiMax operators in 2013 the same as 2008?”

The changed guideline on the BTRC website announces that it is going to award three licences for WiMax.

Officials at the BTRC told the Dhaka Tribune that a few interested parties had already started lobbying with high officials.

The BTRC notification dated August 4, 2008, however, said no licence could be awarded without auction.  

Top Brokers