The Moon may have been formed by a collision between Earth and an object that was strikingly similar in composition to our own planet.
This could help resolve why Earth and Moon rocks are much more similar than we would expect from this “giant impact hypothesis”.
The study is one of three published in the prestigious journal Nature. Two further research papers in the issue report subtle, previously unseen differences in lunar rocks.
Scientists say they paint a consistent – and much clearer – picture of our satellite’s history.
The modelling study, done by researchers from Israel and France, precisely simulates the turmoil of the early, inner Solar System and quantifies the variety of collisions that might have occurred.
In its early stages, the proto-Earth would have been subjected to a string of brutal collisions with other wannabe planets.
According to our best understanding, the last of these was a cataclysmic tangle with a planetary body just ten times lighter than Earth – and the resulting debris eventually clumped together to make the Moon.
The problem is that most of what became the Moon should have come from the imposter – and based on our existing knowledge of what was flying where at that time, that imposter was thought to be a very different type of planet.
But what Dr Hagai Perets, one of the study’s authors from the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, and his colleagues found in their new simulations was that the impactor planet might, in fact, have been made of surprisingly similar stuff to the Earth – leaving only the sort of subtle differences that we do see in lunar material. Specifically, the models indicated a 20% chance that the impact could have been between such similar proto-planets.
Violent veneer
A different challenge to our current ideas about the Moon relates to what happened subsequently. To explain certain details in the Earth’s make-up, scientists have proposed that both the Earth and Moon amassed a large amount of extra matter – a so-called “late veneer” – during a subsequent period when they were bombarded by huge numbers of meteorites.
And just like the original giant impact, this process should also have left a trail of evidence that had not been detected until now.
But for the first time, two new investigations of lunar rocks, one from the US and one from Germany, find support that there was a shift in the balance of the Earth’s ingredients away from that of the Moon; the findings were made by analysing samples from the Apollo missions with new levels of precision.



