Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Rich governments blocking progress, say COP19 observers

Update : 16 Nov 2013, 05:56 AM

Civil societies and campaigners allege that the developed countries are persistently blocking the UN climate negotiations in Warsaw, Poland.

As shocking stories continue to roll in from communities devastated by Super-Typhoon Haiyan in the Philippines, they think there are few indications that the governments of rich industrialised countries will allow the talks to make meaningful progress.

On the preliminary talks on loss and damage mechanism, Lidy Nacpil of the Jubilee South Philippines said: “I left the Philippines two days before Yolanda [Super Typhoon Haiyan] hit, and still now a week later friends and colleagues cannot be contacted. While we fear the worst for our brothers and sisters, rich country governments ignore the devastatingly clear message that climate change represents a planetary emergency requiring emergency measures.”

At a press conference on Friday, she said: “Our communities face new risks because of the new climate era we live in – where the climate has changed because of the historical pollution of the rich. We need an international loss and damage mechanism to support us to manage these risks and respond to the devastating losses that will continue as the climate destabilises. That the governments Australia of the United States would block such a measure is callous, and must cause their citizens great shame.”

Lidy is an international coordinator of Jubilee South, a network of anti-debt coalitions in more than 60 countries across Asia, Africa, and Latin America.

The talks will continue over the weekend, with pressure growing on the issue of “loss and damage” with a rally in the Polish capital to be held on Saturday and an online Avaaz petition started by Filipino negotiator Yeb Sano receiving over 100,000 signatures.

Sano on Friday took an unprecedented step for a public servant by launching an online petition calling on UN countries to take urgent and bolder action to tackle climate change.

In the wake of the Haiyan typhoon tragedy, Sano declared he was fasting to demand action, and today took his call to the next level by appealing to the nearly 30m members of the Avaaz community to back his petition which he will personally deliver into the climate summit.  

Within hours of launching, over 100,000 people had joined the campaign and it is expected to hit over 500,000 by the time ministers arrive at the climate talks next week. 

In his campaign, Sano lays down the gauntlet to all nations meeting in Warsaw to take urgent action.

Climate finance

Brandon Wu, senior analyst of ActionAid, said: “Climate finance and technology transfer are crucial for developing countries, especially vulnerable countries like the Philippines, to be able to confront the global climate crisis. When asked to provide finance now or even just give specific information about how much public climate finance will be forthcoming at what dates, the silence from rich countries is deafening.

“Instead, they have begun pointing to the private sector, even while admitting that private investments cannot meet the needs of the world’s poorest and most vulnerable to climate impacts. This is an unacceptable shirking of ethical and legal responsibility.”

The groups also released a short one page brief, outlining some of the key issues in the international climate finance debate

The talks have been seen by many as a choice between clean and dirty energy, with civil society and youth groups heavily criticising the UN and the Polish Government for allowing corporate sponsors and a “Coal and Climate” conference on Monday to undermine the global call for a renewable energy transformation.

“The slender ray of sunlight in this Polish winter is that there is growing recognition of demands from citizens across the world that the UN talks should focus on transforming our climate polluting energy sector. Despite the best efforts of powerful dirty energy interests to undermine these calls a proposal by the small island states is gathering momentum with many African countries coming on board.” Asad Rehman, head of international climate with Friends of the Earth EWNI, said.

He said this proposal must reflect the people’s demand of securing clean, community controlled energy access for the poor via proposals such as a globally funded feed-in-tariff.

Emission cuts of Japan and Australia

Meena Raman of the Third World Network on Friday said: “The negotiations are supposed to see climate action before 2020 drastically scaled up and to see work on a comprehensive agreement for the post-2020 era agreed.

“Instead we see disgraceful, irresponsible and dangerous announcements by countries like Canada, Australia and Japan that they are going to weaken their 2020 climate commitments. They’re at risk of severely damaging their reputation and of scuttling a future agreement,” Meena said at a press conference at the Summit on Friday.

Mohamed Adow, senior climate change adviser at Christian Aid, in a statement said: “If you are looking for who set back the UN climate talks in Warsaw, then look no further than the two polluting monsters of the pacific – Japan and Australia. Once upon a time, Japan and Kyoto were synonyms for climate action but now Japan will be a byword for bad faith.”

Japan on Friday announced that it would cut greenhouse gas emissions by 3.8% from its 2005 level by 2020 which is actually an increase of 3.1% from the 1990 level.

Japan previously pledged 25% cut from the 1990 level internationally.

"Our energy mix, including the use of nuclear power, is currently being reviewed. In that context, we decided to set this target at this point," Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga said of the new goal.

Hiroshi Minami, Japan's chief negotiator at the UN talks, said the new goal "is based on zero nuclear power" in future. He said the original target was based on a nuclear share of more than 40% of electricity generation.

Yuri Onodera of Friends of the Earth Japan said: “In the middle of the UN conference on climate change where over 190 countries have gathered in Warsaw negotiating to increase their commitments to cut emissions and build a future global agreement reached in Paris two years later, this decision by the world's fifth largest greenhouse gas emitter is a gross negligence of its responsibility and should be revised in line with the level that science and justice requires.”

Japanese climate policy relied on nuclear energy for a long time, which abruptly disrupted when intense earth quake and tsunami hit nuclear power plants in east-coast Fukushima two years ago. A nationwide debate on energy and climate policies by the previous administration led to the nuclear phase-out and steering to renewable energy.

“Today's decision to reverse Japan's climate policy made by a handful of top officials of the administration under Prime Minister Shinzo Abe ignores the will of Japanese public shown  overwhelmingly during a wide range of discussion last fall,” observed Yuri Onodera.

Wael Hmaidan, director of Climate Action Network International, in a statement said: “Japans new targets are outrageous. This will have a serious and negative impact on the negotiations. Withdrawing from climate action is like a slap in the face of those suffering from the impacts of climate change such as Philippine’s.”

Civil society was expecting more from the world’s third largest economic country, but instead they are racing to the bottom.

Japanese CAN spokesperson Kimiko Hirata said: “Stopping nuclear power is not a legitimate reason for lowering their target. There are countries putting ambitious targets shifting their energy source from nuclear to renewables.”

 To abandon the 25% emission reduction target and put forward a target with increased emissions is a betrayal to the international community. One of the most important issues at this year’s negotiations is to address the gap between the mitigation pledges of Parties and the emission reduction needed to keep the average global surface temperature rise to 2℃from pre-industrial levels.

Another problematic country at these negotiations has been Australia, which announced on Tuesday that they wanted to cancel a very successful climate legislation that they have.

Australian civil society is taking to the streets on Sunday to oppose their government’s announcements.

Top Brokers