Bangladesh has 56 commercial banks. I don’t know whether anyone has done any “optimum capacity modeling” for Bangladesh banking. Our economy is growing, the rural economy is becoming more vibrant, and policy planners are being quite loud about inclusive banking and finance.
If our per capita income is $1,190, the size of the formal economy becomes $187bn. With our much discussed large informal economy, the size would be much bigger. Three years ago, The Economist Intelligence showed our economy size as being $137bn. Therefore, many in the government showed the need for a few more banks in 2009. Even some economists close to the government started to champion for more banks, considering the size of the economy and Awami League’s commitment to creating synergy in the rural economy.
I even had a sweet debate with today’s planning commission member Dr Shamsul Alam. While he thought that, considering the size of the economy and the sizeable increases in economic activity, the market could accommodate some more commercial banks.
The World Bank, in 1999, thought Bangladesh had too many commercial banks, with many granted licenses on political consideration. In 2002, while the government of that time again came under pressure to grant more licenses to banks loyal to the businessmen, finance minister Saifur Rahman very loudly said enough is enough: “Let us create pressure on the existing ones to go to the villages, improve their system, process, and platform to serve their clients better.”
I like finance minister Muhith not only for his simplicity but also for his knowledge and for being so articulate. He made a testimony in parliament, in 2011, that the nine new commercial banks were being granted licenses based on political consideration. He was cursed by his party men for being so candid, or maybe for not being very political. Bangladesh Bank, at the very outset, was quite reluctant about licensing too many new banks. We were made aware that one or two of their very competent deputy governors, who didn’t feel good about too many new banks, were summoned to the highest office and cursed for being “anti-government.”
They of course cowed down; file notes changed and the central bank board came out with the same old logic -- the economy has grown larger, clients need better service, entrepreneurs need more finance, and the country’s fast-growing SME sector needs banking services at their door steps.
Bank executives were happy they had many places to go and bargain, some of us were offering consultancy services to the new political leaders-cum-bank owners, most of whom were clueless about banking. Large application books were prepared but the central bank scrutinsers were not given any time to look into the details. The country could witness a “supersonic approval process.”
Though the approval process was “highly intervened” by political seniors, the present condition of most of the nine new banks, tells us it is not so easy for a bank to move on. Banking is a technical business, and sustainable growth is a tough game here. Most of them are suffering, even with large amounts of “insider lending.”
The other day, a journalist friend appraised me for the “quick arrival” of Samudra Bank, to be set up by the Bangladesh Navy. The lady sitting next to him almost loudly said, “then what is the problem with ‘Akash Bank’ being established by Bangladesh Air Force?”
We are aware, our lady entrepreneurs have been talking of a “women’s bank” for the last few years, so are the freedom fighters. This time, in the Digital World 2015 conference, people highlighted the financing problems faced by IT entrepreneurs with some talking about the necessity of an “IT bank.”
I don’t know where this would take us. All businessmen close to governments, or these days, political leaders and other pressure groups, obviously want to get something from prime ministers. Our prime minister, being so kind and so helpful, easily granted licenses to new banks.
Nobody in the central bank or the finance ministry dared ask the question: “Do we improve the present banks’ conditions, cajole or influence them to extend to rural areas to compete with the MFIs, improve their product offering or governance model, or succumb to the pressure to grant new bank licenses?”
These days, I find myself subscribing to the idea of “the Almighty being the most prudent, has given you two ears and one mouth.” Listen more and talk less.



