Legitimately indeed, we have heard of the demand for credible elections in Bangladesh, an event that has not taken place since 2008. Yet, elections alone do not a democracy make anymore than, as the 17th century English poet Richard Lovelace said: “Stone walls do not a prison make.”
What the real opposition (as distinct from the make-believe one) has consistently and steadfastly failed to do since the dubious January 5 polls is present any vision of an alternative, beyond the oft-repeated and vitally important demand for real elections. In almost exclusively emphasising legitimate elections, however, the genuine opponents of the regime forget two of the three “F”s of freedom as it pertains to free, modern societies.
Indeed, free elections, the first F of freedom, are the building block of a free society that seeks to be governed by its own consent. Contrary to what the ruling party pretends to understand, having an electoral exercise with only the ruling party and a tailor-made loyal opposition is not a free election; any pretense of even that election having much legitimacy is out of the window when the electoral machinery from the national commission to the polling officers serves at the pleasure of the ruling party.
Right now, the prime minister can change this sad narrative and test her government’s actual popularity by letting an all-party Election Commission have plenipotentiary powers for 90 days and call a snap general election.
At the same time, given the prevailing ground realities, it will behoove the opposition to come up with proposals other than the caretaker government idea that seems to be a non-starter so far. But what after such a credible election once it takes place and everyone buys into it? I mean, we have had those before, right?
The second F of freedom is free institutions. Much of Bangladesh’s severe problems of governance and even the dubious elections can be traced to the lack of independent institutions that could have garnered the trust of the people across deep political chasms. Whether it is the Election Commission or the Anti Corruption Commission or the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) or any of the dozens of regulatory or law enforcement agencies, the bitter fact is that none of them are much more than an appendage of whomever the head of the government happens to be.
Most such organisations have either no constitutionally-protected autonomy, or the rules of business have made them utterly dependent on the fiscal and human resource largesse of the government of the day. Some of these organisations have very limited statutory powers anyway and even those powers are never exercised – out of prudent caution by career minded civil servants – to control the excesses of ruling party henchmen.
Sadly, I am yet to hear a single proposal from a former prime minister or any of her partners in the democracy restoration movement about how they would go about reforming these vital institutions so that they serve the public without fear or favour. What good would free elections do when institutions simply change from serving one set of political masters to another as a result?
The strength and autonomy of institutions is all the more important for the opponents of the government, because such guarantees alone can assure a sceptical public that the war crimes trials will continue – albeit with much needed due process reforms – no matter who is in office.
Without those aforementioned free institutions, the most essential individual liberties – the third F of freedom – can hardly be protected, as history has repeatedly shown us. Absent free elections and free institutions, there are no truly free people.
We bemoan how there is a dearth of real history and a lack of creativity in public education, while not a day goes by without utter high-handedness by some agent of the state abridging one fundamental right or the another with impunity. It is a matter of abject shame that 42 years into the crafting of the 1972 Constitution, its grandiose guarantees of basic rights of expression, speech, gender equity, travel, and press are celebrated far more in their violation than in their upkeep.
Without these rights, no real historian will dare to examine national history professionally and no creative mind will risk reaching the limits of creativity lest she or he incur the wrath of the state or the mob. And yet, nothing has been heard for a year from the opposition about its plan to protect these rights in a concrete, structured, and actionable manner.
Talk is cheap, and exhortations at rallies are no substitutes for real proposals. Even a modest proposal to actually empower the NHRC to crack down on state-sponsored human rights violators would have been a welcome breath fresh air; but alas, nothing but stale air flows from these rallies asking for a change of government.
This government rests on dubious legitimacy and, knowing that, seeks to keep itself in power through a slow, steady, and methodical curtailment of all that makes a democracy an actual society based on the consent of the governed. It is a tragedy of stunning proportions, however, that the well-meaning detractors of this government are yet to tell us how their version of this democracy will be any more free than the one they seek to replace.
Like other Bengalis, I too await that explanation.



