Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Seeing foes among friends?

Update : 12 Dec 2014, 06:20 PM

Like so many others, I too was shocked by the intemperate outburst about a visiting foreign dignitary by the minister who is also the second-in-command of the ruling party. 

That the outburst incorporated all the worst stereotypes that attaches to men in retrogressive societies is surprising from a seasoned politician who apparently knows the ways of the world. But that surprise is nowhere near the much bigger surprise of the direction of such vituperative: The administration of President Barack Obama of the United States.

Hear me out as I ask you to suspend your disbelief for a few minutes.

The American administration of the incumbent president has been one of the strongest and most effective supporters of the current government in Dhaka whose antecedents are shrouded, to put it very mildly, in a highly dubious electoral exercise that would not pass muster in my alma mater’s student government polls. 

In stark contrast to the largely impotent rhetoric from Washington DC, the actual actions (or lack thereof) of the various levers of the Obama foreign policy machine have been very much geared towards helping the ruling party stay snugly put in power. 

For starters, there is the indelible image of President Obama’s resident envoy in Dhaka literally watching birds on a college campus on the very day that the electoral farce was taking place in early January; had the preference been otherwise, surely the said envoy would have at least gone about to watch these elections take place in the many polling stations that were set up around the country. 

That image came closely on heels of another revealing picture of the worthy plenipotentiary where he was seen proudly donning an emblazoned vest of a major police agency in Bangladesh while speaking to a commencement ceremony of that highly controversial force, underlining further the sympathy there is at Foggy Bottom for this regime.

Lest readers think this is merely a diplomatic courtesy, keep in mind that the American foreign office’s own annual human rights reports in the last three years have pointed out with chilling detail the atrocious behaviour of that police agency in suppressing dissent and violating basic citizen rights with impunity.

It is much more than mere show of support by putting on a ceremonial police vest. The Leahy Amendment is a statute that prohibits American technical support to any law enforcement agency abroad that engages in a pattern of human rights violations, while the broader Foreign Assistance Act specifically forbids any aid to a government that allows such patterns to continue by design or default.

Countless reports and investigations by America’s leading public and private sector organisations – not to mention the many global ones like Human Rights Watch, AHRC, and Amnesty International – have corroborated what Bangladeshi newspapers themselves have pointed out in words and pictures: A country where the space for dissent is being shrunk every day through officially condoned violence on the streets in the day and extra-judicial disappearances in the dead of the night.

Yet, in a strong show of silent support for the Dhaka regime, the Obama administration has studiously refused to invoke either the Leahy Amendment or the broader Foreign Assistance Act prohibition provisions in regards to Bangladesh.

In fact, quite the opposite has happened: The fiscal 2013 budget presented to a fiscally conservative Congress by the Obama foreign policy machine prefaced its half a billion dollar aid request for Bangladesh by praising it as a “progressive, democratic alternative” in the Muslim world!

With that kind of whitewashing of the current government’s increasingly autocratic misdeeds, it is no surprise that the administration of President Obama has done nothing to discourage any multilateral body from providing loans or direct assistance to Bangladesh’s government.

Similarly, no actions have been taken by the American administration to put any of the routine sanctions on individuals affiliated with the Dhaka regime’s security and judicial apparatus.

The human rights situation in Bangladesh is hardly hyperbole whipped up by malcontents. Indeed, America’s own most prestigious human rights award – incidentally named after one of President Obama’s heroes, the late Robert F Kennedy – was given last month to a Bangladeshi human rights lawyer with part of the citation reading “Robert Kennedy would have admired Adilur Rahman Khan’s courage and persistence in documenting his government’s complicity in a wide range of human rights abuses. We are inspired and humbled by his work to improve the lives of all Bangladeshis, and we are proud to honour him with the 2014 Robert F Kennedy Human Rights Award.”

Though the award was presented only a few blocks away from President Obama’s office in downtown Washington DC, the president’s own advisers were visibly absent, probably in a sign of latent support for the government in Dhaka.

That this is the American administration which has incurred the ire of the minister is truly puzzling. The gentleman seems to have lost sight of the forest for the trees. 

Top Brokers