This is not the best time for commercial bank seniors. Though the statistics show that more than 11% of the Tk4.5tn loans are classified, they know for sure if one were to apply qualitative judgment, the numbers would be much higher.
Thankfully, Bangladesh Bank, in view of the turbulent situation in the last quarter of 2013, allowed flexibility to the banks to keep their books regular through rescheduling loans. One does not need to go far – only the Chittagong portfolio of each of the commercial banks can possibly exceed the reported gross classified amount by banks. If one would include the written-off amount, the amount may become massive. It is often said commercial banks can’t lower their interest charge due to large classified or non-performing loans.
Can they realise the classified or default loans? This is a million dollar question. The answer is: Probably not. Since the banks are not at all serious about recovering the written-off loans, we don’t think they can be too serious about recovering classified or doubtful debts.
Besides, there is reported security or collateral shortfall or deficiency, telling us the banks are sitting on large troubled assets. They can obviously go to the courts, but the legal route can only remind us about the East India Company era. Any settlement through courts would take at least five to 10 years.
Banks were very happy with Bangladesh Bank actions early this year, deferring the classification exercise by almost 6 months. Banks could book their year-end profit. The NBR was happy with their tax collection in a dull scenario. Shareholders were happy they could book some dividends due to the inflated profit of the banks. All synthetic solutions.
Courtesy Hall-mark, Bismillah, and other loan failures, NCBs are topping the list with large classified loans. The amount is more than 20% of their total loans.
Again, if we follow a quality drive, the amount may be much higher. Sadly, the large private sector banks are also sitting on surprises. News coming out of them is also too dubious.
There are recurring past dues, security shortfall, excessive lending, and non-payments. Though the situation is much better with foreign banks, the situation may worsen if they continue to increase their loan portfolio or try to reach out to a larger client base.
Usually, one always blames weak risk analysis, absence of a need-assessment culture, weak loan governance resulting in diversion of funds to purchase land, invest in capital markets, or transfer money abroad, political influence helping continuous loan rescheduling, weak information technology or MIS architecture, lack of proper approval covenant monitoring or loan monitoring, poor facility structuring, weak client fundamentals, and maybe political disturbances.
These days however, one also gets to hear about poor risk management skills of the banks’ senior managers, including the CEO, and continuous pressure from the board of directors to increase loan portfolio or to book new clients.
Like the state-owned banks, most of the private commercial banks are managed day to day by the chairman or one or two influential board members, obviously not the managing director or CEO. These directors look after each others’ interests or the interests of their director friends in other banks. When things start to go bad, they simply pass the buck to the poor MD or senior management.
Some would blame the central bank for this sad state of commercial banks. They point the finger at the weak supervision by the central bank. In a country like ours, the central bank too is either helpless to political pressure, or succumbs to vested interests. When accountability is almost non-existent in the government, one should probably not expect too much of it from the central bank.
Most of us thought the days of plundering depositors’ money by only a few large borrowers were gone. We were wrong. Banks are still sitting on large classified loan portfolios or possible bad debts. Each CEO prays the hole is not revealed during his time. He tries to do cosmetic surgery in order to hide the actual situation of the loan books. Some are successful, some aren’t – especially those who are given renewals or tenor extensions. Some of them even have to face the music from the Anti Corruption Commission.
Can the situation change or improve? Of course it can. But for that, we must improve the credit analysis or risk management capacity of the banks. Banks should have better MIS to understand whose loan is being repaid, whose is not, or where the money is going. Loan concentration within a few hands or loans to politically important persons should be stopped, and the majority of the board members should come from independent quotas or among professionals.
The commercial banks must follow one rule: “Don’t put all your eggs in one basket.” Accountants must be able to defend each of their audited reports. The central bank can also think of linking group borrowing with that of the groups’ total equity. Capital market route should be considered by the biggies for any new fundraising. Banks should focus on more credit, risk management training, or certification for their employees including the senior management.



