Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

How to play doctor

Update : 22 Oct 2014, 06:02 PM

In order to maintain the highest grades, we had to read a lot of stuff – both necessary and unnecessary. We didn’t have a fair understanding of the question papers, or even good answers to the questions, in public examinations. It was almost established: In order to get good marks, you have to write page after page worth of answers. We also used to memorise a lot. After almost 40 years, I can finally admit that I had almost memorised a “mathematics made easy” book in order to retain full marks.

These days, be it IGCSE or O level, you have plenty of books, plenty of solution publications, and modes of questions, or possible questions, simplified with answers. Regular questions gave way to MCQs, so that answers could be precise and to-the-point. More importantly, examiners are quite liberal these days – if your answers are right, or if you can reflect a good understanding of the subject at hand, you get full marks. But most importantly, for a good student, apart from good teachers, there is the Internet, and so many other facilities or support are available now.

However, one thing is common between generations both old and new: Only the best ones, or those who want to teach or delve into research and innovation, will go for a PhD. There are many PhDs among my family and friends; in fact, not only did they have to ensure very good grades in their Master’s, they had to work really hard to get there and seek out a distinguished professor who would not only have to accept his or her research subject, but also had to accept to be their supervisor.

Then, reviewing existing literature is a nightmare – you read, read, read, shift your reading to another vast subject, and read again to come up with something unique and useful in the future. Defending your findings or thesis in front of a specialist of that subject, or professors with authority on the subject, is another big challenge. Even then, the quality of the thesis or PhD would vary from university-to-university, or even from country-to-country.

However, no matter whether you are a PhD from Russia, Bulgaria, Poland, India, Malaysia, Bangladesh, Australia, Canada, the UK, or the USA, whether the thesis is relevant to your country or environment, everyone has had to work hard to choose the subject for higher research, get the executive summary or proposal sponsored by a senior professor, do intensive literature review, and come up with a huge book or publication.

I have seen many PhD theses, none of them were less than 1,000 typed pages or so. For most, it is an ability to think beyond the box, to possess a fair visibility about what is happening around them, sponsoring a new idea and obtaining endorsement for it, understanding the research methodology, and of course, extreme hard work needed to finally earn a PhD.

When I joined as a professor at a leading private university, my very caring vice chancellor, some of my senior colleagues, a few well-wishing teachers and friends, and even some junior PhDs wanted to help me obtain my PhD. I was extremely grateful for their kind gesture and helping attitude. However, I really wanted to “earn” that degree, like so many others; but I didn’t have enough time to do any sort of literature review or research into the chosen subject, and come up with solid recommendations or observations that were less-travelled or unheard of in the past, at the age of 50.

To my utter surprise, I see many PhDs among my retired or retiring civil servant and banking friends. I tried asking one of them what his PhD thesis was based on, who his supervisor was, how many years he took to complete his thesis, and how many years of leave he took to study – whether overseas or at Dhaka University –  to complete his PhD. Most of them changed the subject, and a few of them simply smiled.

The simple answer is that most, if not all, never really “earned” their PhD degrees. They either had their thesis done by someone else, or simply managed one somehow, and are now happily moving around with their head held high and utilising their so-called “PhD” into getting promotions or to earn “social visibility” and “respect.”

They have not earned it, like their friends who didn’t earn their “freedom fighter certificate” as they never fought in our war for liberation. They obtained their PhDs by abusing their powers as civil servants or as bosses in the organisation. Sometimes money does speak.

Grace Mugabe, the wife of Zimbabwean president Robert Mugabe, made headlines by obtaining a PhD within two months. Famous poet and novelist Chenjerai Hove has urged Grace Mugabe to return her PhD.

The Norway-based writer thought this to be an insult to the University of Zimbabwe and other students who have to work hard to obtain a PhD. “The lady who received her PhD degree in sociology from her husband has made a joke out of this PhD, and downgraded the image of the university” the writer said. He had graduated from this university, and was a member of its faculty.

What should Bangladesh do about these innumerable “unearned” PhDs? Should the Rapid Action Battalion get into action? Should the High Court issue a rule? Or should the citizenry rise? I don’t have any answers ready. Sorry. 

Top Brokers