My friend did his studies on engineering and business in the United States, and had worked for many years at Ford Motors and IBM. The other day he asked me a question: “What qualification does one require to become a minister in Bangladesh?” I was very intrigued as I’d never come across a job description for a cabinet minister in Bangladesh.
I replied: “Possibly, he or she must be a member of the parliament. If not elected, the person must be a specialist on something or a retired senior civil servant with good command over ministry activities.”
The gentleman smiled and cited a few examples, where the cabinet minister was not even a graduate or, for almost all his life, was nowhere near involved with the activities of the ministry he was running.
Though my friend was pushing me hard, he knew that in Bangladesh, cabinet posts were cherry picked by the prime minister. If you are a party loyalist or an elected MP, you have every chance to be picked today or tomorrow as a minister.
Even if the newspapers publish cartoons of you, don’t worry: As long as the prime minister is happy with you, and you can term the journalist or the newspaper as being against the political party you belong to, your life is safe and you can have fun. You can even make fun of the miseries of the common people.
The other day, I was on a television talk-show discussing our country’s economic challenges and possible ways out, when the host was referring to various recent corridor and newspaper discussions holding the finance minister responsible for all the tensions within and the pressures on our economy and the apparent failure of the ruling party to tackle the economic challenges in Bangladesh.
In reply, I said it was unfair to be passing the buck entirely to the finance minister or even his ministry. We are certain that the level of support and leadership from the “top office” of the republic could have been much better. This issue is difficult to ignore when we see many in the regulatory bodies, businesses, and political hierarchy often bypass the finance ministry and undesirably crowd into the top office.
But the host wasn’t about to leave me be so easily, she continued with the discussion, even after the show had ended, she insisted that we desperately needed a finance minister who could drive our economy to its next possible trajectory, to a middle income country, keeping private sectors at the “centre of the plate” without losing sight of the marginalised.
I was thinking out loud: “If we ever put up a “job watch” for “Finance Minister of Bangladesh,” what should the qualifications of the aspirants be? Should s/he be a chartered accountant? A retired civil servant? Should s/he be from a multilateral agency background? Should s/he be an economist or an MBA having served with a global corporation? Should s/he be from the private sector? Should the person be elected through voting or would anyone from any background do?”
Readers possibly would agree with me that it is a tough decision to prepare even a job watch for a finance minister in a transition economy like Bangladesh. In the past, we had put up economists in this job, they goofed up; we also put up retired civil servants, they were okay but achieved nothing great. We put up people from a multilateral agency background, and they did a good “business as usual” job.
Two of our previous finance ministers were blamed by their own party MPs for not looking after party interests since they themselves were not elected by the people. We often get to hear, or tend to believe, that the finance minister in a republic like Bangladesh can’t also have his own business interests.
Therefore, we may resolve that the finance minister, in a transition economy like ours, should be a ruling party stalwart, commanding respect from the rank and file, with clear understanding about “where the shoe pinches” and visibility about the “destination.”
S/he should mostly be an elected public representative with greater acceptability among development partners and stakeholders. His or her integrity should be beyond any doubt; s/he should also be very articulate in negotiating the “national interests” with the development partners and drive the common causes of the “emerging economies” among the “league of nations.”
One can rest assured that if we now put up an advertisement in the leading Bangladesh and international newspapers/magazines, the number of interested candidates would be few and eligible ones would be even fewer. What do we do then? Run this “possibly the most forward-looking” ministry without a minister? With a public representative of a corrupt and doubtful background? With a “half-hearted” retired civil servant? Or with an “always-shifting-stance” economist?
I am sure that readers are convinced: We have to be extremely careful while choosing a finance minister in a challenging economy like Bangladesh. The case is possibly the same in selecting the right person for health, education, public works, energy, or planning ministries, if not all. We don’t have any plans to develop political leaders to do a good ministerial job. They have often been spoon-fed by bureaucrats, without any ownership.
Gone are the days for an individual with “close sight or visibility” or subscription to “populist thinking” to run a growing economy like Bangladesh, with multiple challenges emerging out of increasing externalisation, globalisation, technological innovation, massive urbanisation, agricultural land erosion, and energy and food security issues, along with under-qualified human resources and frequent “policy paralysis.”
Things have to change. If the political parties mean to take the country to the next level, they must do their homework to pick the right person for the right ministerial role.



