Many years ago, in the heyday of the Awami League and Jamaat being allies in the movement to bring down the first post-Ershad elected government, an idealistic Bengali graduate student had published an opinion piece in the Middle East’s most prestigious broadsheet arguing for the trial of the alleged war criminals of 1971.
It was a duty both for reasons of justice and healing, the essay argued in terms that were perhaps overtly passionate. While the piece was well received otherwise, the author did receive several mails from friends who were painfully surprised to see a supposed “nationalist” playing the “typical Awami card.”
Fast forward more than a decade and a half, the same author received equally painful communication from his AL-affiliated friends when his 2013 column in these very pages pressed for those very trials, now ongoing, to be held in a manner where the goal was transparent justice rather than mere vengeance. Had the author gone soft on “justice”? Had he, a staunch secularist, suddenly become a closet Jamaati, asked at least one email.
I bring up the above issue only to illustrate how increasingly binary we have become in Bangladesh in the political context. Suffice to say, the author in question is yours truly who has found it increasingly difficult to have mature political discussions with most Bengalis, no matter whether it is in person or on social media.
Our groupthink has touched new peaks with lines of demarcation that reach heights (or depths) of absurdity. Must anyone wanting a reckoning of 1971 war crimes be anti-Islam, pro-India, pro-Baksal, and a supporter of Abahani or Sheikh Russel Club, while anyone dissenting from the increasingly autocratic nature of the dubiously elected current regime be a razakar, hater of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, and a fan of Dhaka Mohammedans?
I am increasingly beginning to suspect that such is more likely the case than not, at least amongst the nominally educated classes. The problem with this kind of all-encompassing cleavage is that, taken to its logical conclusion, it strips a neighbour, a colleague, a friend, or a family member of his or her basic individuality and humanity.
Ultimately, we become a nation of three types of people in the eyes of each other: Razakars, murtads, and those too busy or too smart to care. Reducing someone to the “other” is easily done, and yet takes a terrible toll on the social fabric and, eventually, political stability. Even research-based disciplines like economics and history are not safe from such checklists of absolute loyalty as competing versions of financial projections and historiography are blandly accepted as gospel or summarily dismissed as propaganda.
One would like to hope that in 2014, even in Bangladesh, there is political and social space for someone who relishes Bengali culture without being a linguistic chauvinist, who believes in God while despising seventh century obscurantism, and who admires Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’s unparalleled place in national history without considering him a faultless demigod.
That hope remains largely unfulfilled, if the social media, newspaper opinion pieces, and talk shows are any indication. If anything, this rigidity of ideological groupthink has only solidified in the past decade.
Is there a solution? I don’t know. But if there is one, it will have to be from the top down rather than from the bottom up. Crown princes in waiting will have to temper the instinctive desire to lash out, often in remarkably untruthful and disgusting fashion, at the perceived tormentors of their long deceased fathers and grandfathers.
Aging columnists with an unfulfilled Marxist fetish will have to come into the 21st century and stop peddling long worn out conspiracy theories to explain the world that passed them by in their youth. Professors will have to pay more attention to publishing peer reviewed research in their academic journals instead of angling for invitations to another useless talkfest sponsored by this or that “smritiparishad” or another “shangskritikgoshthi.”
I mean, do they really teach different methods of treating diabetes and cancer to members of the AL physicians group and the BNP doctors group (and both these groups exist rather prominently in most medical college hospitals and the Ibrahim Diabetic Centre, for example)? As I said, the absurdity is indeed sheer mind boggling.
Coming back to where I started, at least I can take some relief in knowing that in my case, disapproval did not (as of yet) involve verbal lynching from the legion of apologists of the ruling party in the chattering classes. After all, when the word “razakar” is so easily applied today to renowned Mukti Bahini guerrilla leaders, decorated sector commanders, and pioneering diplomats who risked life and limb to serve Bangladesh in her early years, who amongst us is safe except for those who are professional sycophants or habitual chameleons?
“If you don’t agree with me on everything, you are the enemy” cannot be the operating creed of a society wishing to go forward in the 21st century.



