Precisely 75 years ago, when Russian tanks rolled into Poland to claim their half of the hapless country after the infamous Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, the very first people rounded up to be shipped to the Siberian gulags were social scientists at the universities in Eastern Poland. That many of these historians, psychologists, and economists were socialist and communist themselves did not matter: Their potential danger was inherent in their craft of asking questions that went to the heart of a society’s dynamics.
This roundup of social scientists was a pattern repeated throughout the former USSR’s expansionist history as it sought to remove any alternative thought process in its conquered territories from the Urals to the Baltics to the doors of the Alps. Those who survived the ordeal of exile, forced labour, and eventual release – and few did – were often able to make it to the universities of the United Kingdom and the United States to resume their research and writing where, in their twilight years, I had the privilege of meeting a few such souls myself.
I bring this up because the current Awami League government has reminded us once again that even in 2014, the fear of tough questions and unapproved thought processes remain strong in those whose minds have never matched their words of pluralism.
In proposing a law that seeks to ban donor funded research by independent institutes unless such research is pre-approved by the government, the regime is simply following the thinking – if not the exact action – of many a tyrant through the pages of history: Social science research – based on approval by a government – is not considered valid in any legitimate scientific or professional society. The prime minister’s daughter, who herself is apparently a psychologist practicing in a civilised society, should have been able to inform the PM of this basic reality.
The irony is that the government itself funds many of its civil service training and research programs through donor dollars including millions from the World Bank, the British DFID, and Canadian CIDA among others. The government’s objective is clear: It is very embarrassed by the alternative narrative that is emerging from well-respected independent social research about public perceptions, a narrative that is increasingly at odds with the rosy scenario of peace, prosperity, and democracy being peddled by the ruling party’s spokesmen and sycophants.
Disappointed at being rebuffed when they tried the “such research is not valid” line to question solidly constructed and rigorously reviewed surveys, now they have turned to the heavy hand of legal sanctions against unpalatable truth.
Bangladesh, like most countries with a similar religious and socio-political background, has no tradition of social science research in the sense it is understood in the global academic community. This fact is underlined by the available data from Brookings Institute: On the average, the entire Muslim world produces less than 5% of the world’s peer-reviewed social science research output.
And given that this is social science (rather than capital-heavy physical science) we are talking about, the simplistic excuse of a paucity of financial resources doesn’t quite explain the wide disparity.
That revelation is hardly surprising considering that the crux of social science research involves asking often tough questions that can yield to discoveries that are devastating to deeply held views on society, culture, religion, and other social dynamics.
Just as with other sciences, social sciences also predicate themselves on the scientific method which, again, is premised on free inquiry, robust trial and error, and a wide berth of operation untrammeled by the agendas of those outside the realm of the scholarly or research community.
Those conditions simply do not exist in those parts of the world where ideology – either of an elite or of the majority – holds sway based on the concept of “we are always right and any evidence to the contrary is either wrong or conspiratorial or motivated by ill will.”
The end result is that simple things like GDP calculations or census estimates or even a nonpartisan version of national history remains a distant dream four decades into nationhood, even as uppity heirs apparent jet around the globe proclaiming a “Digital Bangladesh” to politely disbelieving audiences whose own research shows them better.
The last thing Bangladesh needs is for the remnants of its skeletal crew of social scientists to move to those shores where their craft is respected rather than restrained by the barely concealed agenda of a ruling party that is frightened to look at the mirror held up to its shortcomings.
It is a pity that this government is so ignorant of history: Social sciences will far outlast tyrants. If you don’t believe me, try to find the Soviet Union on the map, and then look up the roster of any social science faculty at a major American university and see how many Russian surnames you find.



