Media is spicy again. Bangladeshi depositors have reportedly put in SF372m in Swiss banks. People are making comments about- illegal money transfers, capital flight, rise in political corruption, money laundering, failures of the central bank or law enforcing agencies, weak governance, and even under-invoicing and over-invoicing in cross-border trade.
UNDP sources were quoted to show that each year, an average of $800m went outside Bangladesh illegally between 1970 and 2010. A US-based source showed, on average $1.6bn was sent out of Bangladesh each year between 2002 and 2011.
Having worked in many countries in Asia, Europe, and Africa, I am more than confident this amount of money is not all – Bangladeshis have larger sums on money in banks in Singapore, Dubai, Hong Kong, London, Toronto, or the British Virgin Islands. This is expected from any developing economy with 30-80% of “black money” flowing around in the “white economy,” weak governance, low accountability, and unclear foreign exchange regulations. In fact, the entire concept of “private banking” or “wealth management” grew in the global banks on this basis. The individuals or families with $5m or above in deposits are being provided “extraordinary” services by these “private banking” folks or relationship managers.
If you attend any social program in Dhaka city’s posh areas, at least 10-15% of the people there would be holders of foreign passports, or they will at least enjoy “residency” status in Singapore, the UAE, Malaysia, the UK, Canada, or the USA. The number of Bangladeshi executives joining international jobs is increasing every day. None of them should face any problem in depositing money with any bank in the world or in carrying money abroad. None of the media reports mentioned how many of these Bangladeshi “large depositors” abroad stay in Bangladesh.
All non-citizens or non-foreign passport holders are being identified as Bangladeshis. On any given day, there are more people studying abroad, traveling abroad, or working abroad. Bangladeshi parents with sons and daughters abroad are queuing up for immigrant and non-immigrant visas in the North American or European embassies every day. The queue is getting longer every week.
The size of Bangladesh’s external sector is almost 60% of the $137bn economy. Bangladesh entrepreneurs need easy-flowing money to settle their international obligations, and more importantly take benefits of any “episodic gains” in the international markets. Our present regulatory regime, for obvious reasons, can’t entertain any kind of quick money transfer abroad. I am convinced large business houses in Bangladesh need more facilitation from the government agencies as they need to participate more engagingly in the global supply chain or take advantage of global market benefits. More and more Bangladeshi entrepreneurs are looking forward to establishing their businesses abroad. I know of a few large commodity traders in Bangladesh having to put up cash deposits with foreign banks to obtain “workable trade lines” to participate in global commodity auctions. They needed this in order to participate in the “commodity spot markets” offering better bargains. Establishing letters of credit through Bangladeshi banks would have benefitted them.
I had to tutor the anti-corruption task force during the 2007 caretaker government in their investigations into financial crimes. There was a reported case of a few Bangladeshi entrepreneurs settling $30m in payments from their accounts abroad for buying a “landmark tea company” in assets in Bangladesh.
A colonel asked me how this could happen. I told him some very good tea gardens were on sale by a European owner. A few Bangladeshi owners gained the capability to buy, and more importantly, run those profitably. The seller was very reluctant to sell to the locals. Knowing the Bangladesh exchange control, they not only asked for a higher price, they wanted the money to be settled outside and as soon as possible. I asked the colonel what he would have done if he wanted Bangladeshi owners to buy the local assets of a top-notch European operator. He was silent and afterwards blamed the East India Company’s delineated rules and regulations that are still in practice in Bangladesh.
If we want Bangladesh to move on and for Bangladesh’s economy to march forward, we need to put in our coins for continuous reform of the “regulatory frame-work.” We need to make them keep pace with the changed and changing world. We need our business community to contribute more in national wealth building. We need to help them participate more in the global supply chain and ensure we pick up gains through global market movements. We need our regulators and politicians to be more driven by their heads, not hearts. Private sector-owned media is moving forward, how about the erstwhile East European-minded policy planners?



