Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Blankets from banks

Update : 29 Jan 2014, 06:43 PM

One can easily appreciate Bangladesh Bank Governor Atiur Rahman’s appeal to stand by the cold-stricken people. People, especially bank officials, did come forward to help poor people fight the cold, for understandable reasons. While it was primarily meant for the northern region, we did see blankets being distributed in other regions as well.

A few banks distributed blankets directly among cold-hit people, while most of them gave hundreds of blankets to central bank seniors for distribution. There were a lot of photographs with smiling central bank and commercial bank seniors in the newspapers.

I was engaged with relief distribution among communities affected by floods, river bank erosion, tidal surges, and cyclone Sidr in Gaibandha, Manikganj, Chittagong, Keraniganj, and Pirojpur on several occasions, and can well appreciate the trouble taken to reach out to the affected people in remote rural areas with relief goods.

On many occasions, I found our friends and colleagues to be very interested in the raising and distribution of relief goods, but reluctant to travel to the remote areas. They were happy with leaving relief materials with local union parishad chairmen or members for onward distribution.

These days, I see local NGOs also coming forward to distribute relief goods or winter clothes collected from the well off, or charity organisations. In the beginning, everyone is affected on a humane level, and wants to participate directly in relief distribution. Gradually, their interest fades away, and most of them end up finding an easy way out.

I asked a few managing directors of banks, why, instead of distributing the relief goods themselves, and thereby allowing their colleagues to get engaged in community development, they would leave these relief materials with the central bank for onward distribution. Their reply was that these days, the central bank was pushing banks towards too much CSR (corporate social responsibility), and a photo with a central bank senior serves the purpose far better than taking the trouble of distributing supplies to those really affected.

It has become a kind of quota filling exercise, a few of them opined. I didn’t expect what a central bank senior told me:  Blankets were distributed by one or two banks, even in the native towns of a few Bangladesh Bank seniors.

Knowing the trouble of distributing goods to the badly affected people, one could say, the central bank seniors possibly did a favour to the banks by finding a target market. These days, it is becoming increasingly tough to get enough people crying for alms, or to attend funerals or prayer meetings in urban places.

I met a just-elected member of parliament from Rajshahi the other day. While I told him about our business chamber’s decision to distribute blankets among the people in his locality or neighbourhood and sought his help to distribute those among the really deserving people, he vehemently opposed the idea.

He thought people in the northern region were being too pampered with these blankets every winter. While each blanket can be used for 8-10 years, every year almost 2-3 million blankets were being distributed in a few northern upazilas alone. Most of these blankets were subsequently being sold at a much lower rate to the middlemen, and at times to the shopkeepers who might have originally sold the blankets to NGOs, banks, and charity organisations themselves.

There is a racket operating in and around this blanket distribution in the winter season, he said. The legislator, who happened to be a graduate of Rajshahi University, felt that banks should allocate more money on the long-term and sustainable community development activities, or core capacity development for the marginalised.

All the banks are putting up photographs in newspapers exhibiting their blanket distribution as their CSR activity. Thus, a bit of charity becomes the easy way to satisfy the regulatory commandment of CSR. The really deserving people don’t receive the help they need.

One official at Bangladesh Bank spent much time delineating a CSR guideline for commercial banks, but banks don’t bother to follow this. Even the central bank seniors are confused about the difference between CSR and charity.

Winter is almost gone, but the blanket distribution spree is still on. Banks are under pressure. They want to do more to satisfy the central bank seniors, and if possible, divert their attention away from a fault finding mission.

I know many would be very interested to know the ultimate fate of the blankets being given to the central bank, and their distribution efficiency in reaching the really affected people. Proper storage of these blankets should also be an issue for the central bank.

For obvious reasons, I didn’t want to raise any question regarding whether blanket distributions should be a function of the central bank. Recently, a central bank senior told me that in an emerging economy like Bangladesh, the central bank should not just operate within the traditional boundaries, it needs to go beyond.

Top Brokers