Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The need for democracy

Update : 18 Dec 2013, 06:25 PM

“Bangladesh needs military intervention.”

Rest assured, I didn’t say this. I don’t have the required courage to say this in public. My teachers, who have always been championing democratic values, would have hated me for saying this. My journalist friends, who support democratic institutions to spur on Bangladesh, would have marginalised me. My economist friends, who would always say in the talk shows that countries prosper under democratic rule, would have pitied me. This comment came from the representative of a large apparel buyer from North America. Her firm procures more than a billion dollars worth of designer clothes from Bangladesh.

I was talking to her, sitting in the office of a strategic vendor of Gap Incorporated at the Chittagong EPZ. The vendor exports apparel worth more than $300 million to North America, the European Union, Canada, and Japan. Lately, they have started to export to China too. I thought Chittagong apparel producers were better positioned with the timely export of “Made in Bangladesh” apparel, and enjoying the upside of the capacity and price advantage available for them.

However, the lady told me, that while they still believe that Bangladesh remains an industry champion with very good capacity, diversity, and prices, they were concerned with future supplies from Bangladesh considering the ongoing political situation, and more importantly, not knowing where it was going, and when it may come to normalcy, if at all.

She told me that though they were shifting some fashion retail orders to Indonesia, Vietnam, and China at a bit of a higher price, the factories in those countries were yet to reach the required scale and capacity. High street retailers like H&M and others are yet to find alternate producers in India or Cambodia to gradually replace Bangladesh, she added.

So they are kind of stuck. They like Bangladeshi entrepreneurs. Bangladeshi workers are extremely hard working and always ready to go the extra mile. Sri Lanka or Pakistan can’t let their workers replace their Bangladeshi counterparts, despite better run ports and lower lead time, she continued.

She thought if Bangladesh could maintain its supply side smooth, no matter how the Rana Plaza collapse or Tazreen fire had dented Bangladesh, Bangladesh would remain a star performer from Asia to the rest of the world. Then she said: “In order to maintain the supply chain for the global apparel industry, Bangladesh needs military rule like in 2007-08.”

She is tunnel visioned, only focused on procuring better clothes from Bangladesh at the most competitive price. Bangladesh gives her company a lot of upsides. They, in the recent past, shifted orders from Latin America to Bangladesh, and were planning to give more orders for Bangladeshi vendors to fill up their stores in China.

She was not too bothered about giving democracy a continuous chance to stabilise. She is least bothered with how the local polity is divided, or whether Bangladesh has pro-AL or pro-BNP businessmen, economists, singers, players, university professors, doctors or engineers. She only thought Bangladesh could come out of poverty through massive industrialisation, and thereby generate adequate employment for the surplus labour force.

She thought the Bangladesh manufacturing sector could offer better employment opportunities to even non-resident Bangladeshi workers, like in the Philippines or Thailand, as the need for good workers would continuously rise in the manufacturing bases.

It was very hard for me to answer her. I kept on echoing my recent conversation with a few senior military personnel and university professors: “No, no, military rule can’t be an answer; we must give democracy a chance.”

My economics degree came to play a role to here: Economies can only prosper in democracy. You will see, one day we will be a very respectable democracy with respected institutions to look after the interests of the common people, I said. She became a little embarrassed this time.

With a smile, but firmly, came her reply: “Mr Rashid, with so many people below the poverty line, and an increasing number of people unemployed, you need to let trade and commerce surge faster than in the past, and reap benefits from growing globalisation.”

I had a flight to catch, and she had business to attend to. We both reconciled over a good cup of coffee. But I was thinking that we were all perhaps disconnected from the ground realities. Myths were taking too much time to demystify.

Top Brokers