I didn’t go to the Fletcher Institute to learn diplomacy. I was not supposed to. However, I met many distinguished diplomats at home and abroad. If not all, almost all of them told me the importance of maintaining protocol while trying to forward the home country’s interest in the host country. I don’t think that was the case for Sujata Singh, the Indian foreign secretary who visited Bangladesh a few days back.
It was possibly end of 1973, or early 1974. Sir Colin Campbell, the distinguished chairman of James Finlay from UK, came to see Mr Tajuddin Ahmad, the then finance minister. The local representative of James Finlay facilitated the meeting. The finance minister did meet Finlay’s chairman, but told the local representative: “I doubt whether any Bangladeshi business chief would be entertained, or met by a British minister at 24 hours notice.”
It was 1983. The Ershad regime. The chairman from Grindlays Bank in the UK wanted to meet the president. The local Grindlays Bank representative went to Major General Chisti with a request to confirm the appointment. General Chisti, after knowing the purpose of the meeting, presented a copy of the investment policy to the local representative for their chairman to read instead of unnecessarily spending time with the president, which would have broken protocol.
It was early 1997. Overenthusiastic local executives of Standard Chartered Bank went to the then banking secretary Shah Abdul Hannan, to expedite an audience between their executive director for Africa, Middle East and South Asia, and the honourable prime minister of Bangladesh.
Extremely polite but firm on maintaining protocol, Shah Hannan thought the executive director of a global commercial bank should be very happy to see a deputy governor at the central bank, if not the executive director only. Meeting the prime minister was beyond protocol, he thought.
While the local representative cited the recent example of a CEO of a boutique investment firm based out of Hong Kong meeting the PM, the extremely humble but farsighted Shah Hannan said the result of breaking the protocol was never good.
“Days would be numbered for these kinds of organisations,” he added. He wished Standard Chartered to be a good corporate entity, always respecting the local culture and maintaining the protocol, therefore, not to push him hard for doing something that he was not supposed to do. Just after a few months, the boutique investment firm was no longer in operation.
Sujata Singh visited, and called on the “who’s who” of Bangladesh. This time, newspaper reports didn’t mention that she was carrying any special message from the Indian president or prime minister, or representing any one of them.
We Bangladeshis are very humble. Our leaders always follow an open door policy. There is nothing wrong with that, especially when they get the chance to show warmth and hospitality to a visitor from our neighbouring country. That’s fine too. But the visiting friend giving advice, and more importantly, dictating the terms for our leadership, is not at all acceptable. Diplomatic protocol does not support this.
We came to know about her discussion with the fallen dictator, Jatiya Party chief Ershad. We heard her speech in the meeting with the media. We don’t think a government servant of her stature has the right to speak in that way. She tried to dictate the terms for an independent country like Bangladesh.
The Bangladeshi people will decide who to vote for, and how they expect their country to be lead and run. An Indian foreign secretary can’t tell us they want the election to be held on time, or that if we are not with the government party, Jamaat-Shibir will come to power, especially when she is on an official visit in a foreign country.
How dare a visiting government servant say in public, that if “maximum parties” join the poll, it would be fair and free. Who is she to define democracy for the people of Bangladesh? We have fought our Liberation War directly with deemed-to-be-powerful Pakistan, and indirectly with mightier China and the United States. We will keep on fighting for a just, prosperous, and forward-looking Bangladesh.
India does not want any anti-India activities to be harboured in Bangladesh territory. They want Indian firms or institutions to enjoy due market access in Bangladesh. Fair enough. But it should be vice versa. The present Indian leadership is soft towards a particular family in Bangladesh, it seems.
There is nothing wrong with this. But a government servant under no circumstances should try to dictate the terms for the political leadership, home and abroad. If too eager, he or she should immediately resign, join politics, and run for a parliamentary seat or become a minister.
Shame on our political leadership, shame on our civil bureaucracy, and most importantly, shame on our foreign ministry officials! I don’t know how long they will let us down for their own acute intelligence deficiency syndrome. Bangladesh wants to move ahead, come out of the colonial mentality, and keep its flag flying high in the world.
Salute to all the freedom fighters and 1971 civil and military leadership in the month of victory. Felicitations to all our entrepreneurs, teachers, journalists, non-resident Bangladeshis and workers, for their commitment towards a better Bangladesh, despite all the challenges. There are days beyond today.



