The conviction earlier this month of two expatriate collaborators from the War of Independence underlines the stark chasm of hubris that separates emotionalism from reality when it comes to the ongoing war crimes trials.
One of the convicts is an American citizen now, while the other is a British subject today, facts which essentially ensure that they will never face the punishment that was awarded to them by a tribunal that the entire international community has found woefully lacking in basic due process safeguards.
Those who wanted to go full steam ahead with trials, disregarding considered international opinion from friends, are the only ones to blame from this miscarriage of justice which will likely see two people accused of the most heinous crimes live happily ever after.
Any criticism of the due process standards of the trials is invariably met with the nonsensical “where were they when …” line of argument, followed by the “well, it is our court and our law …” line of reasoning, and ending with some silly analogy to Nazis, Nuremberg, and Israel.
Fine and good, but that is exactly the definition of hubris that impresses nobody except the echo chamber of sincere but unrealistic, like-minded intellectual types. The painful reality is that Bangladesh is a small country whose democratic antecedents and judicial independence are, at best, not fully established in the court of international opinion.
That fact alone should have prompted those with common sense to make the International Crimes Tribunal (ICT) above reproach, rather than the caricature it has unfortunately become.
When the government unilaterally appoints the judges, the prosecutors, the investigators, and some of them go on to seek the ruling party’s parliamentary nomination, only the most partisan or ignorant will term that set-up a symbol of due process.
Add to that the political reality that there was never any doubt as to what verdict was expected in each case, and that the choice of counsel for each of the accused was limited by the government.
The question was not whether horrendous crimes were committed or not. It was not even if many of the accused were involved or not. Rather, the only question was if we were going to come into the 21st century and prove their guilt beyond doubt in a court of law whose proceedings were beyond reproach.
In our rush to satisfy emotional cravings and political expediencies, we woefully failed to answer in the affirmative to that only question that mattered about the ICT. The price we pay will range from the apparently mundane (stigma for the judicial process and endless deadlocked appeals) to the heavy (expatriate convicts never being extradited).
If the goal was to feel emotionally vindicated, we succeeded handsomely. On the other hand, if the goal was to punish the perpetrators, we have likely failed, at least partially.
The issue is of particular resonance to me because long before the ICT was a cause célèbre of the present regime, I was writing in the international press about the abject necessity of holding these trials to come clean with history.
The present government’s reckless politicisation of the trials and the sycophancy of the ruling party’s allies in the intelligentsia are disappointing to many of us who long wished to see a judicial reckoning of the crimes of 1971, but now get to see only an emotive and politicised farce that is beneath the dignity of a proud and fair people.
We deserved better. We still do.



