Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The Indo-Pak proxy war

Update : 13 Nov 2013, 06:21 PM

Despite being an avid reader of Harold Robbins, James Hadley Chase, and Arthur Conan Doyle in my school days, I never thought I had the minimum qualifications to comment on the intelligence agencies of our part of the world.

However, my cadet college connections, regular associations with senior officials of the armed forces, defence and security analysts, and my attendance at some of the sessions at the defence training and research institutes helped me gain an interest in the intelligence activities in Bangladesh.

Since the end of the 80s, and the early 90s, we have been hearing about the ISI of Pakistan being the root cause of some destabilising activities in Bangladesh. Many times the ruling Awami League government, some in the intelligentsia, and journalists, kept pointing fingers at the ISI for encouraging terrorist activities and Islamist groups in Bangladesh.

Awami League stalwarts even blamed BNP of conniving with ISI in anti-national security activities. Many of them pointed fingers at the ISI for the August 21, 2004 grenade attacks on the then opposition leader Sheikh Hasina and her party. Indian senior politicians and civil bureaucrats also thought Bangladesh territory was being used by the ISI for anti-India activities and terrorism.

Since early 2009, we have been hearing much about the Indian external intelligence agency RAW being engaged in undesirable activities, including trying to dent the image of Bangladesh’s armed forces. A few retired defence officials, security analysts, and opposition politicians pointed fingers at RAW, accusing it of involvement in the tragic BDR mutiny.

Though I see no visible evidence of their activities in Bangladesh, I am told that RAW has been successful in accessing many security establishments and networks to safeguard the security interest of India.

A few from the Indian diaspora in Bangladesh, particularly some journalists, editors, teachers, cultural activists, civil bureaucrats, and economists, are rumoured to be in the “favourite” list of RAW, and have become their natural allies.

However, the good part is that RAW and the ISI are more interested in making sure their own country’s interest is served, rather than helping Bangladesh build a respectable security network and anti-terrorism platform. Many in India think anti-India activities have been on the wane since the present government came to power.

They also think the present government can serve India’s security interests better than BNP. We have seen India’s pre-eminent intelligence agency successfully using PTI (Press Trust of India) to influence leading Bangladeshi editors and reporters to publish reports accusing Khaleda Zia of taking money from Pakistan’s ISI during the 2001 election, referencing Pakistan’s higher court proceedings, which turned out to be a hoax.

Many media analysts are confidently telling us that the recent Anandabazar Patrika-led campaigns against the possible BNP government through the next election is also RAW-fed. The ISI has been blamed for encouraging terrorist activities, fuelling religious militancy, the ten-truck arms haul, anti-India militant activities, and taking advantage of the weak security in Bangladesh. Bangladesh, unfortunately, has apparently become a fertile land for an ISI-RAW proxy war.

The Research and Analysis Wing, or RAW, is the primary external intelligence agency of India. Formed in 1968, after the Sino-Indian war in 1962, and the Indo-Pak war in 1965, it is entrusted with the monitoring of political, military, economic and scientific developments in countries which have direct bearings on India’s national security and foreign policy.

It is also involved in the security of Indian nuclear programs and the moulding of international public opinion with the help of the Indian diaspora. The joint intelligence committee (JIC) under the cabinet secretariat is responsible for coordinating and analysing intelligence activities between RAW, the intelligence bureau, and the defence intelligence agency.

The effectiveness of the JIC has varied since the formation of the National Security Council (NSC) in 1999, while the role of JIC has been merged with NSC. RAW’s legal status is also unusual. It is not an agency, but a wing of the cabinet secretariat, hence it is not answerable to the Indian parliament. This keeps it out of the Right to Information Act. However, allegations of corruption and human rights violations have to be reported.

RAW was instrumental in the formation of Bangladesh guerilla operations and the organisation of the Mukti Bahini. It was responsible for supplying information, training, and heavy ammunition to this organisation. While its failure to prevent the Bangabandhu killing earned it a lot of criticism, it has reportedly played a role in successfully thwarting plans to assassinate Sheikh Hasina by Islamist extremists.

The Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), established in 1948, is the premier intelligence service of Pakistan, providing critical national security and intelligence assessment to the government of Pakistan. Although, the joint chiefs’ committee was created with a mandate to coordinate all military exercises and operations of the Pakistan armed forces after the intelligence gathering failure of the Indo-Pakistan war in 1971, the ISI remains the most powerful organisation, always calling the shots in Pakistan.

Two arch-rivals, RAW and the ISI have been always trying to outwit each other, to dictate the terms for Bangladesh. At times RAW was successful, a few times the ISI was successful. Ill-prepared security networks, paid and unpaid agents, friends, and loyalists in Bangladesh also played significant roles here.

Members of the Indian or Pakistani intelligence forces were patted on the back by their seniors and the government for doing a good job, though not necessarily good for Bangladesh.  

Top Brokers