The prime minister has been commendable in the sheer consistency of her message, to development partners abroad, that Bangladesh will hold polls just like other democracies do, with the incumbent government in office at election time. Team after team of European and North American journalists, politicians, and academics have been given the same message in the hope that they will make common cause with the prime minister’s supposed common sense approach.
The problem for the prime minister is: despite what her courtiers tell her, Europeans, North Americans, and Australasians are not exactly naïve; they know as well as we do that the “democracy” practiced in London and Ottawa is as different from the one extant in Dhaka, as milk is from water.
It is true that British, Canadian, and Australian governments remain in office when elections are held. What is also true is that those governments are not pseudo-autocracies where one person holds the offices of prime minister, leader of the House, defence minister, establishment minister, and party chairman.
Nor do these democracies have prime ministers who have the unquestioned power to nominate party members for parliamentary seats, unilaterally appoint members of the election commission, and hand-pick police and paramilitary chiefs.
And that is only the tip of the iceberg of the difference between Bangladeshi “democracy” and the ones that the prime minster claims to want to emulate so conveniently at election time. No minister in a British or Canadian or New Zealand cabinet will last 24 hours in politics were he to propose legislation that puts government officials and policemen above the law of the land, as the Bangladeshi cabinet has done by bringing amendments to the Anti-Corruption Act and the Police Ordinance this year.
In a place like Canada or Australia, ministers resign in shame when their corruption is brought to light by civil society groups like Transparency International. In today’s Bangladesh, ministers thunder threats of violence and human rights organisations have their offices ransacked by policemen when such corruption is unearthed.
This prime minister, for all her talk of democracy, has not been much different from her chief opponent in gutting the most basic structures of democratic governance, making bureaucrats even more unaccountable for their misconduct, and attempting to silence the last few organisations left outside of her absolute control. What she presides over may be a democratic edifice; it is hardly a democratic system.
Bangladesh can have elections like “other democracies” when Bangladesh becomes like “other democracies.” Sadly, neither the prime minister nor her main opponent (and predecessor) have shown any respect for the concepts of dissent, tolerance, and accountability that are fundamental to the functioning of a real democracy.
When the Anti-Corruption Commission indicts a sitting ruling party MP or a cabinet member for corruption, or when the police arrest violent student leaders of the ruling party, then the prime minister will have some standing in her claim to being just another normal democracy. Until then, she is fooling only her most sycophantic courtiers and nobody else.



