An economy is a big, complicated beast, and one of the things about them is that they have to add up. Therefore any one measure we have of it is only a snapshot. But it is also true that each of those snapshots must agree with each other -- the economy, all our different measures of it, must add up.
As an example, there's a claim that has been running around American politics for decades now. That productivity has been going up and up -- the amount produced by each hour of worker labour that is -- but that wages haven't been following. This is appalling. The rich are taking everything and therefore the revolution etc.
But as Paul Krugman has pointed out, and he has a Nobel so we should pay attention, if wages are not rising with productivity then the labour share -- the amount that goes to workers -- of the economy should be falling and that to capitalists rising. Which, over the period being pointed at, isn't true.
Therefore we know that original contention is wrong because the economy doesn't add up if we accept it as being true.
Another example, the currently fashionable anthropologist Jason Hickel has claimed that British wages were below subsistence levels from the Industrial Revolution up to the beginnings of redistribution in the 20th century. An interesting idea, certainly. But if wages were below subsistence for a century and a half, then the population must have been falling for that period of time. That's what subsistence means and also what below it does.
But the British population tripled over this time and there was another 100% of outward migration. So, we know the original contention is wrong. We don't need to check the calculations -- unless it's just for fun -- we know we can reject them. Economies add up, you see?
Which brings us to something less happy about the Bangladeshi economy. As the current government's investigations about the last one are showing not all the numbers we were told were necessarily wholly true. “Over the past few years during Awami League’s regime, the inflation rate was shown to be 9-11%, as the highest possible rate. However, the white paper committee formed to deduce the actual state of Bangladesh’s economy finally revealed that actual inflation may have been 15-17%.“
And that's a problem. Because it means we're poorer than we thought we were.
Measuring the economy itself is possible, just about. We get to a pretty good guess about GDP for example. But that's nominal GDP. The amount of economic activity going on in numbers of Taka. We've then got to subtract the inflation rate to get to real -- inflation adjusted -- GDP. The inflation rate is more difficult to calculate. It's also easier for the government to put the thumb on the scales.
If the government reports one inflation rate, then sets the Tk/$ rate to reflect that, then if the actual inflation rate is higher than that, the Taka will decline against the dollar more
My favourite example of this is when one Argentine government tried to jail some economists for independently estimating the inflation rate. Argentina -- to try to make up for the mess of the previous government -- had some bonds that paid interest linked to the inflation rate. So, the government was under-estimating (you might prefer the phrase “deliberately lying” but I couldn't possibly comment) the inflation rate and was most, most, upset when people started to try to discover the true interest rate that should be paid.
If the government -- the last one, obviously -- undercounts the inflation rate then that increases “real” economic growth by reducing the amount of nominal growth that is just because each Taka is worth less.
Ah, but we've already said that economies must add up. So, what happens here then? It's a standard economic assumption that over the medium term currency exchange rates are equal to -- the changes in them are -- the relative inflation rates in the two currencies. So, if the government reports one inflation rate, then sets the Tk/$ rate to reflect that, then if the actual inflation rate is higher than that then the Taka will decline against the dollar more. Which would lead to the official Tk/$ rate being overvalued, to the foreign currency reserves of the country being depleted, a shortage of dollars at the banks and so on.
Anyone want to think back to six or 12 months? Read the archives of this column back a few years? There was continual pressure on the exchange rate, were shortages of dollars at the banks, the foreign currency reserves at the central bank were declining.
Oh.
As I say, economies must add up. One thing here means this other will happen over there. For economies are systems and systems do indeed balance. A useful point to keep in mind more generally, not just about the recent past.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.



