Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

How the white paper committee uncovered the length and breadth of AL’s corruption

Renowned economist Zahid Hussain, a committee member and former lead economist of the World Bank Dhaka office, speaks to Dhaka Tribune’s Meraj Mavis about how the actual state of the economy was covered

Update : 05 Dec 2024, 06:05 PM

Over the past few years during Awami League’s regime, the inflation rate was shown to be 9–11%, as the highest possible rate. However, the white paper committee formed to deduce the actual state of Bangladesh’s economy finally revealed that actual inflation may have been 15%–17%.

Like this calculation process of heuristic estimates of experienced inflation, Dr Zahid Hussain mentioned that an attempt was made to follow whatever was necessary, and in whatever manner deemed appropriate for the subject or topics in preparing the white paper.

The report stated that the process was structured under three broad pillars, viz., (a) mobilization of the team and related logistics; (b) data generation, information collection and consultations; and (c) consolidation, drafting and validation of the report.

How it came into being

“We had two main questions to prepare the report. First, where are we now? Second, what is the reason we are standing here (regarding economic instability)? To keep this in mind, we tried to collect official data from specific sectors, such as the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS), Bangladesh Bank (BB), Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission (BSEC), Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies (BIDS) etc. Where it was not possible to get updated data, information was collected by contacting and discussing with focal points.”

“Again, there were some sectors, like corruption, where there was no data about who were the main beneficiaries of this corruption. In those cases, an idea was taken by discussing with the stakeholders. Those who have dealt with them,” he commented.

“A lot of meetings were held in Dhaka with those stakeholders. An attempt was made to sit with various government and non-government organizations, businesses, experts, and civilian groups. In this process, we also collected information from outside Dhaka; three main divisions Sylhet, Chittagong, and Rajshahi through the same process,” he explained.

“While collecting this information, we initially thought that politicians were the main beneficiaries of corruption. After collecting more data and information, it seemed that businessmen, and finally bureaucrats, were also found as primary beneficiaries.”

Explaining further about the process, Zahid Hussain said: “I, for example, did the chapter on banks. First, I tried to find out the actual status of their balance sheets. I first collected media reports. For example, I tried to find out which banks' names came up in stories like S Alam and Beximco. This way, I selected 10 listed banks and took the balance sheet information from their websites. Those balance sheets, of course, showed that everyone's condition was quite good.”

However, a bank's balance sheet is a financial snapshot that shows the bank's assets, liabilities, and equity at a specific point in time. It's a key tool for analyzing a bank's business and how it finances lending.

“Along with another expert, I started reviewing the reports. The attempt was to find out where the banks' cash was: with themselves or with Bangladesh Bank? Then, the information was collected from the bankers and stakeholders through the key informant interview method.”

A key informant interview (KII) is a qualitative research method that involves in-depth interviews with people who have first-hand knowledge on a specific topic.

“Again, suppose that in the case of the chapter on inflation, the primary data was first collected from BBS. Then we tried to see whether the perception that people had about the BBS data was an illusion or whether it had an objective basis.”

“We did this by contrasting the BBS data with the reports of several domestic and foreign organizations at the time. We observed a discrepancy in the inflation calculations when comparing the BBS report with those of the World Bank (WB), Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD), Dhaka Chamber of Commerce & Industry (DCCI), and BIDS. We found the differences by multiplying 1.5, 1.7, 1.8-1.9, 1.9, respectively.”

“Therefore, instead of the CPI's 9–11 % range, we said in the report that the genuine inflation may have been in the 15–17 percentage range.”

Regarding the final process, he explained: “After collecting the data, we each gave a paper presentation on our own different topics in the seminar system. Then the opinions of other members of the white paper committee were taken. Based on all of that, a review presentation was made in the second round, and then the final paper was submitted.”

Remedies

In the last part of this report, various suggestions have been given to the current government.

In this regard, this economist said: “We did not discuss reforms because there is a special committee for that.

However, the current government has been suggested to prepare a mid-term plan, which could be for 2-3 years, as a guide for moving forward, and some suggestions have been given on which issues should be emphasized in the next budget.”

Finally, the renowned economist said: “We tried to highlight the current situation in the country and explain the reasons behind it, and that is what we did. The paper provides a thorough analysis of the current state of affairs in the nation. But possibly this report could have been produced in greater detail if we had had more time. But we intended to fulfill this obligation on schedule.”

Top Brokers