Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The economics of zakat

Update : 10 Aug 2013, 02:14 PM

A television reporter interviewed me the other day about reasons for the lower flow of zakat to rural Bangladesh this year. I asked him a return question – was he aware of the total amount of zakat distribut-ed each year in Bangladesh?

The gentleman didn’t have any answer. Subsequently I have asked the same question to my business school seniors who work with the government revenue administration. They didn’t have any definitive an-swer, but reckoned totals would be 30%-50% more than the income tax being realised from individual in-come tax payers in Bangladesh.

Income tax earnings by the government amount to Tk 300bn, out of which roughly Tk120bn comes from individual tax payers. Our preliminary estimates show that the total zakat being distributed across Bangla-desh each year is around Tk150bn or $2bn. I have come across many individuals in Chittagong who are happy to minimise or err with tax obligations, but who never compromise with their zakat payments.

Rich people in Muslim countries, including Bangladesh, usually share a portion of their assets with poor relatives or neighbours in the same community to distribute as zakat. Even though zakat is meant to help poor individuals or families come out of poverty through income generating programs, zakat in Bangla-desh is mostly being used to buy saris, lungis, mosquito nets, and charitable items among poorer people.

There is no effective or structured method for zakat distribution in Bangladesh. Too often, rich people buy charitable items for distribution via relatives, local government representatives (union council chairman or members) or mosque imams and head teachers at local madrasas. Some also distribute clothes or food in orphanages out of their zakat money.

A few also buy rickshaws, carts or fishing nets to help poor people in rural Bangladesh into income gener-ating activity. Some people are seen using zakat for extension, refurbishment or repair of mosques and other religious institutions.

Few are also seen using their zakat money for building rural schools, libraries or helping poor students through scholarships. I have not come across anyone using their zakat funds for medical treatment of dis-advantaged people.

Bangladesh government’s zakat Board does not have a structured process for zakat administration, collec-tion and distribution. As currently administered by the ministry of religious affairs, general people face a “trust gap” with the zakat Board’s management. Many people feel the board does not follow the proper or Shariah compliant way of zakat management even though the National Board of Revenue has made con-tributions to the zakat Fund tax advantageous.

Other Muslim countries have come up with a structured approach to zakat collection and administration. Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and especially Malaysia have all set positive standards. Pakistan engages NGOs to help make effective distribution of zakat.

Few countries however have shown success in integrating zakat funds with “social safety net” programs. Some recent discussions suggest the social business model being championed by Nobel Laureate Professor Muhammad Yunus could help with key zakat objectives.

No doubt, there could be a better way of zakat money management in Bangladesh. Presently money is not flowing adequately to deserving target groups or causes in the community. My personal experience over the last fifteen years includes zakat items being distributed to families having sons in the police department and armed forces.

Newspapers have in the recent past reported stampede deaths during the distribution of zakat by political leaders in Chittagong, Dinajpur and Noakhali. Due to non-existence of a proper distribution network, peo-ple in more remote areas do not get an adequate share of zakat funds. It has also been observed when political leaders, particularly in election years, spend money through zakat, most of this cash goes to vote banks or repairs of religious institutions.

Surprisingly the zakat flow to rural Bangladesh this year is reportedly lower than before. Relevant reasons could be reduced business in capital markets and real estate, election uncertainties and associated reshuf-fles of candidates by the two major political parties.

No matter how much the total zakat amount built up each year in Bangladesh, the present system war-rants review and further alignment with the national poverty reduction and distributive justice strategy. The truly needy should be targeted as beneficiaries for zakat money.

We should see this money being distributed more for bringing a person or family out of the shackles of poverty.

During the era of Prophet Hazrat Omar (RA), it was observed that due to the effective distribution of zakat among poor people for income generating programs, the total of targeted beneficiary groups reduced each year. Bangladesh Islamic Foundation has translated and published a relevant book by Moulana Yusuf Al Karzavi on zakat philosophy and management.

The best way of zakat distribution is to ensure funds are utilised by the marginalised to bring tangible im-provements in their lives.

Top Brokers