Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The bane of reform

Update : 05 Jul 2013, 04:28 AM

Nobody who knows me even half well would confuse me as an admirer of the ruling party.

Nonetheless, it is hard not to detect the sharp smell of rank opportunism in the efforts of critics who are bemoaning the government’s effort to take-over that legendary institution – Grameen Bank.

Don’t get me wrong … I have little doubt as to the less-than-noble intentions of the government in its rather shameful treatment of the micro-lender and its Nobel laureate founder.

But the blame should rightly be placed not at the door steps of a prime minister, a party, or a cabinet member; rather, the real culprit is our political culture whose foul stench emanates from both major parties in abundance. Ours is a political culture that, for all its protestations of democracy, is anchored in the precept of centralised absolutism.

That such absolutism is validated by democratic elections at regular intervals does not take away from its substance. Simply put, the Bangladeshi political context does not have any tolerance for independent centers of influence that are not directly controlled by a central authority, be that authority a president, a prime minister, or an unelected chief executive.

Grameen Bank’s problem is that it has garnered a prestige and influence of its own that makes it a threat to that absolutism. And it is not alone.

Forty years into the constitutional promise of empowered local governments and independent national ombudsmen, we find a shadow of the former and no trace of the latter.

All the seminars and tall talks of autonomous commissions to fight bureaucratic corruption and human rights abuses would be funny, except that the jokes are squarely on us.

The last time the head of the supposedly independent national human rights commission made a policy statement, for example, it was only to "suggest" that the government "undertake an investigation."

Heck, I could have suggested that, and that too without the expense of having the fanfare of a national commission created by law!

Or, take the police for example; every party in opposition wants reforms, just until the day it is sworn in as the government; at that point, almost by magic, the chant is taken up by the party of the outgoing ministers almost overnight.

This of course leaves the poor retired inspectors general of police (IGPs) to write perennial articles about how badly reforms are needed to make the police something more than the appendage of the ruling party of the day. As to why these IGPs never instituted even limited reforms when they were in office, well you will have to ask them.

On and on, I can go and talk about the Election Commission, the securities and exchange commission, and a whole lot of statutorily autonomous bodies and supposedly freely elected sports boards, but the story is the same – They are no more than glorified extensions of the executive, headed by pliant bureaucrats, or favoured industrialists in ill-fitting suits and garish neckties.

The glaring fact that is obvious to all who read the news is that decision-making, from something as trivial as the color of furniture at a deputy secretary’s office, to the weightier issues of public procurement is in the domain of the executive.

And that executive itself has more centralised power than any British Governor of Bengal had, for no governor of the Raj ever combined the offices of prime minister, defense minister, establishment minister, leader of parliament, and leader of the ruling party in the same person.

In fact such centralisation does not even happen in neighboring India and Pakistan anymore, let alone in the more advanced democracies in the cooler climes.

Such a raw concentration of centralised power is the bane of just any kind of meaningful reform in governance at any level in Bangladesh.

So next time the leader of the opposition or one of her deputies questions the supposedly dictatorial tendencies of the current government, someone ought to ask the toughest question of all: Were you any different and would you be any different?

The fault lies, to paraphrase Shakespeare, not in the party of any given prime minister, but in the notorious stars of our political culture that are light years away from being remotely democratic.

Top Brokers