Precedence is a double-edged sword. Courts often hear the argument of precedence mainly because such interpretation meet with the approbation of the judges. Customs too, are used to resolve social disputes on similar grounds.
Then again, there’s the other side of the argument manifested further by two recent events in the ever evolving (or should one say the regression) of politics and democracy. The army coup that removed a government elected just a few months ago in Myanmar will go down as a disturbing precedence. The impeachment trial of the US president is even more of a consternation.
Barring the US that imposed soft sanctions on a few individuals, no other country has progressed further than expressing softer regrets over the happenings in Myanmar. Anyone watching the US Senate’s trial against Trump will be hard put at to come to a conclusion other than that politics prevailed.
The Myanmar army has actually garnered support from countries that described the takeover as an internal affair. Those that were quiet or soft either had strong economic or even political interests in mind. Given the brave reaction of citizens, including abstention from work, the army intervention is decidedly unpopular.
Yet, democracy hasn’t prevailed. When a convoluted constitution was raggedly and astonishingly agreed to by the army and politicians for restoration of the people’s will, it left the army very much in control. China has effectively scuppered attempts of the toothless United Nations to censure its ally.
For all the growling of “severe consequences,” Secretary General António Guterres knows deep down there’s little the UN can do. It is a mirror image of prior attempts to censure Israel courtesy the US’s opposition. The military rulers have promised elections in a year or so, probably under the same constitution. Whatever the future holds, it is unlikely that the will of the people has much chance of expression. It’s a case of a few deciding the fate of millions.
Similar has been the case in the US. Democrats did a great job of the “build-up” strategy of the dastardly attack on the Capitol. Where they failed was to incontrovertibly prove Donald Trump’s direct call for insurrection. Defense lawyers didn’t help matters by terming the trial unconstitutional in that Mr Trump is a private citizen now.
The astonishing bit was that no one questioned the fact that the Senate had agreed it was indeed constitutional, and that the trial proceeded after the winter break by which time he was truly a private citizen. The voting went as per expectation, except that seven Republicans voted with the Democrats. Here too, it was politics that prevailed. Nearly half of the 75 million voters that supported Trump in the elections agree a third party is needed in the US.
Trump had hinted at this previously. His closing remarks on January 6 certainly emphasized that “this is just the beginning.” The Republican mindset was on the 2022 Senate elections and how the Trump base would react had they voted otherwise. A great many of them are waiting for the next directional guidance.
Mitch McConnell may have tried to play to reason by clearly holding Trump responsible for the riots both in his closing speech and an op-ed. Amazingly, he fell back on the constitutional argument in justifying his vote against guilt. It’s not the first time, nor will it be the last, that intellectual dishonesty has overtaken the “greater good” of the people.
Healing the divide was an election pledge for Joe Biden. He hasn’t been able to wade into that, given the flurry of executive orders required to undo Trump policies and pursue a budget that’s one tenth of the US GDP for further coronavirus stimulus. The only route left is for court challenges of Trump’s alleged misdemeanour. Whether that’s divisive or cohesive will pan out. One thing is for sure -- Donald Trump isn’t going to go out of the public eye. The real danger is the US political system denigrating to Third World levels.
Mahmudur Rahman is a writer, columnist, broadcaster, and communications specialist.



