Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The post-pandemic threats

Globalization has connected the world, but has also created heightened inequality

Update : 19 May 2020, 09:56 PM

The global draconian response to curb the Covid-19 pandemic has led to a shutdown of economies, causing wide-ranging effects. People below or at the margin of the poverty line are hit the hardest. 

Since the shutdown, they are in shortage of the basic necessities of life. Two months into the lockdown, we are thinking about a “new normal,” ie opening up socio-economic activities in a limited scale, cutting down non-essential expenditures, and reorienting our attitudes to work. However, for most of the global population, the post-pandemic period will perhaps bring out new threats.

The economic shutdown has rendered visible the inherent inequalities of the pre-pandemic economic system. Amidst global economic growth, socio-economic uncertainties have become persistent for a huge group of people whom Guy Standing in 2011 referred as the precariat.

They have been habituated with instability in income and living standards. They rely almost entirely on wages despite income insecurity. This is why the precariat is not the same as the proletariat. 

The income unsecured waged labourers are resultant of the “neo-liberal” economic model that aims to achieve profit through market competitiveness and flexible labour. Market competitiveness has transferred production bases to the countries with cheap labour cost and enabled a massive increase in labour migration, part-time work, freelancing, etc. Labour market flexibility has transferred the responsibilities of coping with economic risks and insecurity from the employers to the workers. 

The economic fallout will lead to a massive surge in unemployment in Bangladesh, which will be much higher than the official number of unemployed population of 2.7 million as per the latest Labour Force Survey -- 2017. 

Regrettably, most of these newly unemployed people -- the precariat so to speak -- will not directly fit into the safety checks of government’s rehabilitation programs.

Bangladesh is uniquely positioned to face severe post-pandemic threats. During the last 30 years, the country has experienced extensive economic growth. Along with facilitating the unprecedented economic growth, people involved in the booming sectors like labour migration, start-ups, freelancing, and garment industries have acquired new identities and lifestyles. 

In the post-pandemic new normal condition, many workers will fall into economic hardship and loss socio-professional identities. The long cherished middle-class/stable life towards which people were drugged by the instantaneous consumerism will appear unattainable. Aspirations will be replaced by grave despair.

Consequently, this will disrupt social cohesion at large.

Since January 2020, around a million migrant workers have returned to Bangladesh and they are uncertain about returning to a job of similar nature. The Gulf and Southeast Asian countries host around eight of the 10 million Bangladeshi migrant workers, maximum of those are at the verge of being jobless due to the economic shutdown and declining oil prices. The return of the migrants is a major setback for our remittance inflow.

Moreover, there will be crises at the individual familial level. Most migrants are from poor rural families. Their remittances over the years have supported entire families. Thereby, they have significantly contributed to the poverty alleviation in Bangladesh. The whole process is now in jeopardy and could possibly reverse the socio-economic progress.

The reduction of familial income will not only force these families into economic hardship. This will likely to have a severe psycho-social impact. The usual drivers of their family’s prosperity will become burdens.

We are yet to develop a skill transfer system, which would have allowed these returnee migrants to deploy their skills locally. Moreover, due to social conventions, many would hesitate to do the un/low/semi-skilled jobs in Bangladesh that they did abroad. Thus, millions of people and their families will need economic and psycho-social supports. 

The conditions of people working in the RMG sector are no different from the migrant workers. There are chances that in the post-pandemic situation economic activities will surge up. However, the rippling effect of the overall economic shutdown will severely affect peoples’ purchasing power and spending styles. Thus, coming back to normal will be a long journey. Many workers are already laid-off and the number will only increase in the near future. 

The situation of garment industries in Bangladesh reveals inequalities at different layers of the worldwide economic system, which has become common due to the economic flexibility under globalization. For example, recently, British retailer Debenhams has gone under administration but at the back end, all of their overseas employees and suppliers are facing crisis. 

Debenhams has terminated all of its employees in its Bangladesh office following the British regulations. However, it contradicts with local directives as the Bangladesh government had declared that there would be no laying-off or furlough of workers during the pandemic. Moreover, at the supplier end, Debenhams has $69 million in liabilities. They will go down with the bankruptcy of Debenhams but will hardly receive any compensation. 

Similar uncertainties are looming over the start-up sector of the globalized economy. Following the pandemic, many start-ups are forced to cease operation or at least lay-off staff. Many of the Bangladeshi start-ups in sectors like finance, health, education, transportation, hospitality, and deep technology are facing plummeting demand due to reduced consumer spending. 

The Venture Capital and Private Equity Association of Bangladesh reported that around 300 start-ups are likely to incur revenue decline of approximately $53 million in sales. Export-oriented start-ups have experienced as much as 80% decrease in revenue. This will endanger jobs of 150,000 direct employees and about 700,000 associated service providers. 

Globally, to cope with the economic downturn, start-ups have stopped online advertising, cut salaries of employees, laid-off full-time employees, stopped or slowed down hiring. For the start, the business-to-consumer start-ups have seen decline in revenues, which will gradually affect the business-to-business start-ups. Eventually, every economic sector worldwide will suffer financial setbacks. 

A recent report by the World Economic Forum reveals that in China industrial output dropped by 13.5% and retail sales decreased by 20.5% during the shutdown of January and February. If a similar reduction in output and sales happen globally, roughly $28 billion in start-up investment will be lost.

Similarly, the freelancers and part-timers are likely to face backlash in Bangladesh. There are about 500,000 active freelancers. The number of part-timers is even higher. World Bank revealed as much as 19% of the total employed population in Bangladesh is working part-time. Many freelancers and part-timers are likely to be unemployed in the post-pandemic situation. Thus, a threat of exponential increase in the rate of skilled/educated unemployment is imminent. 

One unique feature of the start-up or freelancing sector is that the employees hardly receive any on the job training and must invest on the tools and equipment. The employers do not provide or protect any such investments. For example, product delivery and ride-sharing platforms require the employees to own their personal vehicles. During the shutdown, these investments have become liabilities for the employees. An economic shutdown is making the stark inequalities visible that that neoliberal approach to economy has made appear normal.

A pervasive global economic system has connected the apparently different sectors, industries, countries, and region. In today’s world, all the workers are also consumers. To remain profitable under economic shutdown businesses have reduced number of employees. The jobless workers could not consume as normal. Hence, businesses experienced a sharp drop in demand, which in turn has led to closure of businesses and more workers being laid-off.

The paradox of the flexible economic systems under neoliberal capitalism is that it forces people into economic adversity who in turn cannot spend in consumption. Thus, a downward spiral is set into motion. Karl Marx has prophesied this inevitability of the inherent problem of capitalism 200 years ago.  

The economic globalization has connected the whole world but also created heightened inequality amongst classes. The precariats form a unique class in history because they usually have higher educational qualifications than required by the jobshe/he can expect to obtain or be required to do. This imbalance will only increase in the post-pandemic time generating a deep frustration as well as anger about the impossibility of having a sense secured life.

A progressive agenda for restoration must reach out to them sooner than later. Otherwise, the frustration could lead them to the far right political affiliation or be captured by the revolt of the elites leading to a quick fix than a genuine change of the order of things as Arjun Appadurai has recently argued.  

Mohammad Tareq Hasan is an anthropologist and teaches at the University of Dhaka.

Top Brokers