Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Is this China’s weight to carry?

The early days of the outbreak in Wuhan may have been mishandled

Update : 16 May 2020, 12:22 PM

Due to the coronavirus, millions around the world are suffering. With nearly 3.2 million confirmed cases globally, it is testing the limits of health care systems in every one of the 210 affected nations.

Added with the death count nearing 300,000 globally, it is creating an unprecedented crisis that has left the world in a state of frenzy and despair. Apart from the grave human cost, the economic toll this crisis is effectuating is nearing the point of becoming irreparable. With no definite cure or long term solution to provide hope of defeating this pandemic, mankind is struggling to foretell what the future beholds.

In a timeline formulated by Axios, it is shown that the first known patient of the novel coronavirus began displaying symptoms on December 10, 2019. In the span of six days, health official in Wuhan linked the strange conditions being displayed by the patient, making him immune to generic flu medication, with the wildlife market in the city. 

On December 27, the Chinese authorities were officially made aware of the virus. Following that, Chinese authorities, as well as the World Health Organization, announced that no evidence of the novel coronavirus being communicable human-to-human was found. 

To determine who may be liable for this crisis can be decided by evaluating the reports and facts put forth by Chinese and international media. Although according to the South China Morning Post, contradicting the aforementioned timeline, the first case of coronavirus was recorded on November 17, 2019 in the Hubei province of China. The same article also stipulates that five patients on average were being tested positive from then onwards. 

In addition, China consistently failed to reveal data that would have provided evidence of human-to-human transmission for a period leading up to three weeks from when they were made aware of this. 

Failure to do so is a breach of Article 6 and 7 of IHRs. Another breach of the aforementioned articles occurred when Chinese authorities provided erroneous and wrongful information to the World Health Organization in regards to the number of active infection during the period of January 2, 2020-January 11, 2020. 

Despite being a party to CITES, China failed to proscribe the sale and consumption of animals, via the consumption of which animal-origin viral infection can be spread. This is a breach of Article 12 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights.

Furthermore, the lockdown of Wuhan, the place of origin of the novel coronavirus, was put into effect on January 23. Although evidence suggests they were apprised of its human-to-human transmission, nearly 5 million people were allowed to leave Wuhan before the lockdown was initiated. 

This act of negligence by failing to prevent the people of Wuhan to travel, along with spreading misinformation regarding the severity of the virus, deprived many countries of formulating pre-emptive preparations to deal with the pandemic. 

According to a study conducted by University of Southampton, if China had acted three weeks earlier than they did, as well as enforced the lockdown of Wuhan with immediate effect, the number of Covid-19 cases around the world could have been decreased by a massive 95% -- significantly mitigating the chance of it becoming a worldwide pandemic. 

Nevertheless, China’s statutorily granted sovereign immunity right prevents individuals and businesses harmed due to the coronavirus from suing them. Though this right can be revoked, as seen in 2016 when the US Congress passed the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act. It enabled the victims of the 9/11 terrorist attack to sue the government of Saudi Arabia for complicity with alleged attackers, and seek compensation for the damages they faced due to the 9/11 attack.

Additionally, China is a member of United Nation Security Council. Such a position allows them the power to veto any move made against them by other states. If any nation tries to put forth a resolution that aspires to seek monetary compensation from China due to the mishandling of the pathogen, they can exercise their right as a member of the Security Council by simply vetoing the resolution, rendering it impotent. 

A popular idea that was circulating was if a default judgement can be obtained, it may be used to seize any commercial asset owned by China in order to compensate for the financial losses borne by countries in an attempt to combat the coronavirus. 

Unfortunately, the vast majority of China’s commercial assets are within the physical territory of China, therefore, cannot be seized by aggrieved nations. However, the aforementioned litigation will be a fantastic tool to investigate and determine the severity of Chinese complicity in the mishandling of this global pandemic.

Wasif Jamal Khan and Sabiha Mehzabin Oishee are Founders, Bangladesh Forum for Legal & Humanitarian Affairs.

Top Brokers