Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The tragedy of essential workers

We have never given them the appreciation they deserve

Update : 30 Apr 2020, 08:45 PM

“We must start the wheels of our economy to save the country.” 

This is an underlying principle of the current coronavirus response policies in Bangladesh. 

Despite the risk of Covid-19, those considered essential workers, namely, health care providers, law enforcement agencies, food producers, and distributors continued working. Even the garment industries have run in limited scale during the last month, and are now aiming for business as usual. We are expecting these workers to help recover the country and the economy.

Workers -- now considered essential -- that kept the country wholesome during the pandemic, unfortunately, are ill-paid, do not have access to proper Personal Protective Equipment (PPE), and are not shielded by social/medical insurance.

Except the added risk of Covid-19 looming over, nothing is new in terms of their situation. Even before the Covid-19 outbreak, their salary was scantly, and they had to work day and night for the benefit of the top tiers of the society.

Though termed essential workers, they can be labelled as disposable workers.

For instance: Law enforcers at the front lines are at a great risk, as they are involved in disinfecting streets, ensuring social distancing, helping people go to hospitals for treatment, and tracking people who violates quarantine. But they do not have enough safety equipment as visible in the footage of news reports.

We are taking a note of them being at risk of Covid-19. But do they normally have enough resources? I doubt it. 

According to a recent Prothom Alo report, Bangladesh’s police force has more than 200,000 members. Many of them stay in the police centres where eight to 12 persons must share a room. Thus, if any of them gets infected by Covid-19, there is a risk of mass spreading. The threat is imminent, as more than 250 police staff have been affected and one killed so far.

At the front lines of health care, 440 doctors have tested positive for coronavirus and two have died till April 29, arguably due to a lack of PPE. A recent study by BRAC University found that 25% of doctors and nurses and 60% of medical support staff had treated Covid-19 patients without PPE. Is it because they are ignorant of the potential risk? No, because our public spending in health care is low. 

In a 2019 opinion piece, Mercy Tembon of the World Bank argued that public health spending of Bangladesh is less than 1% of GDP, whereas among the countries at the same income level, the average of health expenditure is 2.3%, as per the estimates of WHO. The Covid-19 pandemic is revealing the loopholes that GDP growth had kept out of sight by thin layers of illusion over the years.

If we look at the front lines of our food supply system, we again find signs of grave neglect and inequality. According to PPRC Governance and Economic Survey 2015, the average monthly income of people in rural areas -- with agriculture as the major income source -- is Tk18,349. The amount is significantly less than the national average monthly income of Tk31,883. 

Further, if adjusted for inflation, real income of the rural population has decreased by 9.73% compared to 2012. Overall, in Bangladesh, the average monthly income of the bottom 40% of the population is Tk10,657, whereas for the middle 50% and top 10%, the average monthly income is Tk25,763 and Tk147,388, respectively.

During every harvesting season, we find news about peasants not getting fair prices while price hikes at the retail market in cities are commonplace. Thus, people involved in the supply chain only gain profits. Coronavirus may be aggravating the problem of the peasants, and pushing to cut the share of the usual benefitting segments also.

At the front of export income, the garment industry is the main thrust of our economy. Economists are forecasting a crisis, as global brands have cancelled more than $3 billion worth of work orders. But were the garment workers paid enough before the pandemic? The answer again is a big no.

After repeated protests, minimum wage for garment workers has been set at Tk8,000, which is insufficient if we consider it in comparison with the poverty line income, or the cost of basic needs. According to the latest Household Income and Expenditure Survey 2016, the minimum requirement for household consumption expenditure is Tk15,420 per month. Frankly, garment workers merely survived all these years, despite having brought billions of dollars for the industry owners.

During the normal times -- food producers, health care professionals, garment workers -- the essential workers of the country did not even get enough to survive with dignity. Now, during the pandemic, essential workers are forced to work at the front lines. If the workers do not resume production, the socio-economic setback will hit the capital owners hard.

For instance, garments owners have become worried as factories started to run in China and Vietnam. They are the main competitors of Bangladesh for a market share of apparel products. The concern is about keeping market share and profit intact. But, regrettably, the profit share will hardly reach the workers at the frontlines. 

In one way or another, our neoliberal-capitalist priorities are responsible for the current crisis. Due to the capitalist logic of profit, all around the world, we have neglected food producers, health care professionals, and labourers, favouring the big corporations. 

Peasants and industrial workers have continuously been alienated from the products and values that they produced or manufactured. Once the Covid-19 pandemic has halted the whole economic process, workers at the front lines are there to bail us out from the crisis. 

Ironically, we have not looked after the people whom everyone is considering as essential workers now. 

Many have predicted out of despair that an apocalyptic event of some sort will end the demon of capitalism. But it is unlikely. The tragedy for the workers is that Covid-19 will not end their misery; rather, it is setting a stage for its renewal.

Can we retreat from this harrowing tragedy? Yes, probably, we can. 

Firstly, we must stop pushing human footprints into the animal world, making it difficult for the viruses to mutate and jump over to affect humans. Secondly, we must adopt an alternative lifestyle based on sharing, solidarity, empathy, and equity, and not competition and profit.

Mohammad Tareq Hasan is an anthropologist and teaches at the University of Dhaka.

Top Brokers