British Prime Minister Theresa May has initiated the process for the eventual exit of Britain from the folds of the EU.
On March 29, President Donald Tusk of the European Council was handed over a letter in this regard.
The significance of this dynamic has been reiterated through May deciding on an early parliamentary general election in Britain.
The triggering of Article 50 is raising many questions. As pointed out by Andrew Duff, a former Member of European Parliament, the Brexit process is complex and would require at least a two-year negotiation. This will induce a lot of debate, scrutiny, and internal consideration.
It is expected that the Article 50 secession treaty will be enacted in 2019 as a council decision. What is clear is that red lines of the UK government, in particular concerning the freedom of movement of people and the role of European law and the European Court of Justice, will make it impossible to strike a deal modeled after EFTA/EEA membership.
There is some clarity about the UK’s position on the single market and the customs union.
It will have to be a comprehensive deal that minimises the impact on the trade and investment flows between the UK and the EU and at the same time permits Britain to be selective regarding in-migration and strike trade deals with the rest of the world.
A negotiation
The EU27, besides satisfying the European parliament, might also react unfavourably to any mercantilist behaviour, for example with regard to corporate tax.
However, before both sides can even enter these negotiations there will have to be a successful conclusion of the withdrawal agreement.
From a negotiation perspective, reaching a withdrawal deal without any payment is highly unlikely. The EU will not simply scrap its demands in the face of UK opposition. At the same time without a withdrawal deal, there is little chance of transition arrangements or a long-term trade deal.
This will fuel the arguments of those in the UK who believe that a quick exit will be better in any case, and that this situation can eventually be helpful in concluding trade deals with other countries.
Economists are also pointing out that there is likely to be a significant cost to the EU because of Brexit. According to estimates, the UK’s eventual withdrawal could leave a financial gap of 14-19%, or between 20 to 27 billion euros, which the EU would need to deal within 2019/2020, in the next Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) or earlier.
The Scottish government, adamantly opposed to a hard Brexit, has been pushing for an independence referendum between autumn 2018 and spring 2019
This would depend inter alia on whether any transition agreement or “phased process of implementation” with the UK is concluded, how the issue of the exit bill is settled, and whether the negotiations last for two years are extended or would collapse prematurely.
It is also agreed that as EU-UK negotiations are expected to develop in parallel with the next MFF negotiation process -- they should add momentum to the overall pressure to reform the EU budget which has been mounting across the EU independently of the Brexit vote.
This could serve not only to achieve a better financing system, but also to contribute in restoring citizens’ trust, and to reopen or further the discussion on other fundamental financial reforms in the longer term, such as the creation of a Eurozone budget.
However, given how hard the upcoming negotiations on the future MFF promise to be, it remains to be seen whether such effects could prove to be more than wishful thinking.
Agree with you, the council does
While the secession treaty will be negotiated mainly by the European Commission, the political agreement on the future partnership will be achieved mainly by the European Council.
This requirement should prevent the Article 50 treaty from being treated as a “mixed agreement” that would then require national ratification by all 27 states.
The UK, after invoking Article 50, will be transforming itself from being a member state into a third country.
Its participation, consequently, in ongoing EU legislative and judicial matters during the coming two-year period will be highly sensitive.
This change in the ballgame has to be treated with great caution by the UK.
They will have to take care not to overplay their hand in matters of security intelligence, foreign affairs, and defense.
The transition will be complicated and will need careful oversight. Consequently, serious consideration needs to be given to set up a special body, answerable to both parties, to oversee, over a longer period, the full completion of Brexit.
Such a Joint Transition Authority (JTA) could then be charged with the task of managing the phasing-out of the UK’s rights and obligations to the EU, and vice versa.
The JTA could also be charged with settling the disputes that will inevitably arise during the period in which the Brexit deal is being implemented.
This would avert unexpected difficulties and avoid a rush to costly and lengthy litigation in both the British and European courts.
This authority could also advise and ensure that relations with Britain do not fall off the agenda of the EU27 once the UK has left.
The ghost of William Wallace
The Scottish government, adamantly opposed to a hard Brexit, has been pushing for an independence referendum between autumn 2018 and spring 2019.
The UK government has stated that there will be no referendum before the outcome of the Brexit process is clear.
However, if the signs point towards a bad deal, leaving the EU quickly with no deal in advance of such a referendum might make it harder for the Scots to vote to leave the UK.
Nevertheless, Scotland could still vote yes to independence after Brexit, in a process compliant with the constitutional provisions of the UK.
The EU will then have to decide how to manage the accession process if an independent Scotland applies for membership, accepting all associated conditions.
This would be a difficult scenario, but, in the end, the EU would accept a country that fulfills the accession conditions and has expressed such a strong desire to remain part of the European family.
The dynamics will be complex and will require patience from both Britain and the EU.
Muhammad Zamir, a former Ambassador and Chief Information Commissioner of the Information Commission, is an analyst specialised in foreign affairs, right to information, and good governance. He can be reached at [email protected].



