Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

What do we really mean by sustainable?

The definitions are nothing if not murky

Update : 29 Sep 2019, 09:38 PM

We need more clarity and transparency on the issue of sustainability and, particularly, what constitutes a sustainable product. This is far from a black and white issue. Recently there was a report about the health risks to workers who are using Potassium Permanganate spray (pp-spray) to create the faded look in denim. 

Because of concerns about the use of pp-spray, some apparel brands and retailers have been asking their suppliers to switch to alternative methods to create used, faded, and other “effect” looks on denim in recent years. Generally, this has involved the use of sophisticated lasers to create denim etching effects.

More sustainable right? Well, that depends. For instance, the retailer might now know that the denim effects were created in a manner that is not harmful to workers. But what about the cotton used in the denim? Was it conventional or organic cotton?

The consensus these days -- from brands at least -- seems to be that organic cotton is referred to as sustainable, while conventional cotton is not. Often brands issue press releases proclaiming that by such and such a date, all of their clothing will be produced using sustainable cotton -- they are usually referring to a cotton standard.

This sounds good but even this is not as clear cut as one might think. The most up-to-date research, commissioned by the C&A Foundation, actually found that organic cotton consumed 15% more bluewater than conventional cotton.

Other research findings suggest that there is a lack of clear evidence that cotton standards that brands are moving towards being more sustainable. The reason is two-fold. 

First, there is a lack of robust data on these issues. Secondly, conventional cotton production techniques in the likes of Australia and the US have improved significantly in recent years, yet these improvements are often not factored into the most up-to-date research on these issues.

Let’s go back to a brand looking to source more sustainably. They want to source only from factories that use lasers to create a denim effect looks. More sustainable? Probably, yes, and certainly better for workers. 

They want to use only denim made with cotton which adheres to a leading cotton standard. More sustainable? We don’t really know. But there are also other factors to consider here. What if a brand wants to source garments that are made from only recycled fibres, including recycled polyester? 

More sustainable? In theory, yes -- large swathes of the apparel industry are moving towards recycled polyester in their collections, despite the fact that in many cases it is associated with a price premium. 

Yet we must also consider that even though a garment is made from recycled fibres, the factory where the garment was made could have used fossil fuels for its electricity supply, thereby increasing the garment’s total environmental impact. 

In the case of products made in China, where a large amount of the world’s recycled polyester is produced, this is highly likely the case, as large parts of the industry are coal-powered.

One could go a step further and say that the fibre itself is often of secondary importance in terms of the environmental footprint of a garment and its sustainability. 

We need to consider, for instance, that the production of fibre depends on energy and other materials beyond the fibre feedstock to produce things such as heat, electricity, fertilizers, pesticides, feed, dissolution chemicals, and so on. 

These could be classed as secondary flows and, in many cases, they are potentially much more significant than the raw materials which are used as a fibre feedstock. This is the thing about the issue of sustainability -- it is an absolute quagmire of an issue.

There are also other factors. What about the country where the products were made? To stay on the example of denim production, we know that many manufacturers are moving towards techniques that use less water and that brands are increasingly asking their suppliers about how they are addressing this issue. 

That is positive and, all other things being equal, a pair of jeans produced using less water is more sustainable than ones that are not.

But, we know that all other things are not equal. For instance, a pair of jeans produced in a water-stressed region are, in theory, placing a higher environmental cost on the local environment.

And, of course, we know that many areas of the world are now experiencing issues of water-stress so it is questionable whether any product which is created using as much water as it takes to make just one pair of jeans can really be called sustainable.

The overriding message in all of this is that there is a stronger need for clarity and transparency of the language used right across the textile value chain -- from manufacturers to brands right through to end consumers. 

Often there is no justification to describe a garment product as sustainable, and often using this language simply leads to confusion.

There is a need to tell users more specifically about how a product was made and the environment it was made in. Where was it made? What materials were used in its production? What were the environmental and social credentials of the factory in which it was made? What certifications does it adhere to?

There are a number of clear-cut criteria that can be included in a product. It’s time for our industry as a whole to decide what these should be and the language that is used to describe them. Then let consumers themselves decide whether or not the word “sustainable” is appropriate.

Mostafiz Uddin is the Managing Director of Denim Expert Limited. He is also the Founder and CEO of Bangladesh Denim Expo and Bangladesh Apparel Exchange (BAE). He can be reached at [email protected].

Top Brokers