Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

All the water we need

How can we produce a system which delivers clean water to all?

Update : 01 Jun 2019, 10:08 PM

Just because something is important, it doesn’t mean that we should be asking the government to either do or ensure it. 

Actually, given the effectiveness of various governments, greater importance might well lead to our arguing that anyone but the government should be in charge of it. Which is where I differ with the editorial of this newspaper -- no, it’s OK, columnists are allowed to do that. Sometimes. Maybe.

For we have the argument that fresh drinking water -- to be polite about it, free of the results of people having drunk it earlier upstream -- is very important. Indeed it is, the lack of it is probably the greatest killer of human beings over history, and certainly causes more child deaths than anything, even the infectious diseases we now beat with vaccines. 

So yes, important, we want, as soon as we can, to make sure that all have access to potable water. So far, I agree, and there is praise for private sector businesses which are bringing clean water to the masses.

Then we are told that: “While such projects are good to see, and more such start-ups will only provide much-needed respite to our rural community, a concern of this magnitude should not be the responsibility of socially conscious entrepreneurs but rather the government and other authorities associated within the affected localities.” At which point my reaction is: “Ah, no, not really.”

Which is where we get the difference between those who are idealistic and those who are, like me, purely pragmatists. That second group being those who simply and only are interested in the result.

Sure, I like freedom, I’m all in favour of liberty. I agree that government is sometimes necessary, that taxation to fund it, is needed. The important question -- both for those working from logic and theory and also those like myself -- is when should it be the government that is used to solve a particular problem?

Use this example of clean water that doesn’t kill those who drink it. We all agree that this is a desirable goal. Our possible difference is in how we reach it. The invocation is that because it is important, therefore, the government must undertake the activity. Which is, as above, where I differ.

One argument is that given that the government hasn’t done so, historically, then leaving it to the government is unlikely to produce it. We can still argue that “should” if we wish, of course, we can. But should we so argue, that’s the question under discussion.

To argue from that history, it never has been the central government which pushes out the supply of clean water to the population. Even the Romans, aqueducts and all, weren’t using the empire to do that. It was a function of rich people in each city trying to buy local social prominence by building things. 

The complex irrigation systems of Iran -- and other areas -- we call Qanat didn’t depend upon central government either, but voluntary cooperation within the affected communities. Leaping over that history to the modern systems of the rich world today, none of them was created by that central bureaucracy.

A mixture of municipal government projects and private sector activity produced those systems. France still, to this day, largely gains its water from private sector systems. 

The British system was private and municipal built, nationalized and then sent back into the private sector upon efficiency grounds. 

Those municipal supplies could indeed fit into the stricture above, “authorities associated within the affected localities,” but even then it would be fair for us to distinguish between that and central government.

We could even take a step further and say that the government has a role in regulation. A water supply system is a natural monopoly after all -- no one is going to suggest building two sets of water and sewage pipes to the same set of households so that we can have a competitive market.

But our actual question, stripped of all ideology, is how do we best produce a system that delivers drinkable water to all? The answer, currently in Bangladesh, the private sector is better at doing this. Therefore, to a pure pragmatist like me, it should be the private sector providing that water.

Don’t worry, there is still a place for ideology in this. Once we’re all rich enough to be able to indulge our theoretical structures then, well, we can. A rich society can lose a percentage point or three on doing things in the right manner by moral values. 

A poor one doesn’t have that luxury, things must be done in the most efficient manner possible so that more of those necessary things can be done.

My usual statement at this point is that there are some things so important that we cannot use markets to reach those goals. The modification here is that only when a place is rich can it afford to replace markets -- the poorer we are the more we’re dependent upon using them.


Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.

Top Brokers