Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Feeling the crunch

What is the difference between an illiquid bank and an insolvent bank?

Update : 18 May 2019, 09:42 PM

The Bangladeshi banking business is going through something of a liquidity crisis. The leasing industry is suffering for the same reason -- all of which is ably explained in one of the all-time great movies, It’s a Wonderful Life. 

Try looking up the clip on YouTube or similarly called “Wonderful Life, bank scene.” It’s the best popular explanation of the perils of banking yet made.

The banks are currently finding it difficult to pay back all the depositors who want to take their money home. The leasing companies -- which gain the majority of their funding from the banks -- are having exactly the same problem. 

Either they cannot extend new leases because they can’t gain deposits from the banks that fund them, or they’re having problems repaying their old depositors because they've not got the cash to hand.

There’s nothing very unusual about this, it’s something to which the basic system itself is liable. We could call it a bank run, we can call it a liquidity crisis, even a fundamental feature of banking. Fortunately, we also know how to solve it. That’s what the central bank is for.

The underlying problem here is fractional reserve banking. We deposit our money in the bank and it doesn’t just sit there in the vault, awaiting our return. Instead, it is lent out to other people to build houses, buy business equipment, spend on their credit card. The bank lives on the difference between what the borrowers pay in interest and the depositors get paid in interest. Most of us get this instinctively.

Fewer of us go on to make the next connection, which is that if we all turn up and ask for our money back today, we can’t have it. Because the bank doesn’t have it. It’s in those houses, business machines, credit card bills. We’ve all got to wait for those to be paid back so that we can extract our deposits. 

Sure, obviously, the bank keeps a bit of the money in cash in the vaults, so that if some fraction of us wants to take our money away, we can. That gives the name to the whole system: Fractional reserve banking. 

The bank has enough cash to be liquid in normal circumstances, can handle the usual -- or a bit more -- number of people coming to withdraw their deposits.

If everyone turns up, then it can’t, and the bank is “illiquid.” This would normally mean bankruptcy, but that’s not a good idea. So, the central bank steps in and provides that cash needed. But only to those banks which are only illiquid. 

If all the loans were paid back and the bank still had some over after repaying all deposits, then the bank is solvent but illiquid. If it’s insolvent -- even if all loans were paid it still couldn’t pay off every deposit -- then it should be closed anyway. 

Even then, we still have systems to make sure that the small guy doesn’t lose his money -- deposit protection schemes. Only the big firms, who can be thought to know better and investigate the soundness of a bank, are left to carry any losses.

That’s what the system is, and it is inherently fragile. The obvious question is, well, why do we put up with this? Why do we willingly adopt a system that is liable to fall over like this? The answer is that it’s also valuable. Without doing this, we don’t get “maturity transformation.” 

You and I, near all depositors in fact, only want to put our money into the bank for a few weeks, a few months. But the lady trying to buy a house wants to borrow for 30 years. Someone, somewhere, needs to change our short term deposits into that long term loan. 

That’s maturity transformation, and that’s something that fractional reserve banking does. Without it, we couldn’t do it. We think it’s valuable to have it, so we put up with the problem. Reduce it, with the central bank and so on, but only reduce, not eliminate.

The current liquidity crisis in Bangladeshi banking? It doesn’t really matter why it has started -- that fragility of the basic system again. That it has is all we need to know. And the extension of it to the leasing industry, well, that’s just what will happen given the first part. The thing is, left untreated, this is dangerous. But we have a central bank to provide liquidity if needed, and that’s the very reason we have a central bank.

This doesn’t mean that the government should just print unlimited money to hand out – there’s a good reason to make the financial system sweat a bit in order to shake out the difference between those who are illiquid, and those who are insolvent.

The importance of all of this being that yes, there is a problem. But we’ve already solved it by that creation of the central bank in the first place, which is why we go to the trouble of having one -- to be able to solve this sort of problem that we know the banking system sometimes causes.


Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.

Top Brokers