As you read this, Paris, the capital of one of the most developed nations in the world, is in a state of lockdown. In a scene more reminiscent of autocratic nations, close to 90,000 police personnel have been deployed across France to control nationwide rioters, with the government currently considering declaring a state of emergency, if the current protests by the Gilets Jaunes, or the yellow vest-wearing protesters, become more widespread, violent, and uncontrollable.
For those who came in late, the yellow vests movement is a nationwide uprising by French civilians (who in a show of unity wear the yellow vests, which are legally required to be carried by all motorists in France) against the Macron-led government’s now-abandoned attempt to place additional taxes on fuel from January 2019, in order to mitigate fossil-fuel consumption, which contributes significantly to global warming.
While France has been the host to the momentous 2015 Paris Agreement signed by 196 countries to reduce global warming, its civilians apparently don’t quite agree with the premise, though there’s obviously more to this than such a simple summary.
Fuel taxes in France have broadly risen in 2018 by around 16%. The effect of these taxes has been felt more by individuals, because a significant number of businesses and professions are able to gain fuel tax leeway from the government regularly. Such anomalous instances -- where businesses are able to work around fuel taxes -- can be found in other nations across the developing spectrum too. For example, last year, five private power plants in Bangladesh were allowed to import fuel oil without taxes being levied on them.
In the current French context, while France is attempting to up the fuel taxes, European Commission figures show that across the Eurozone, similar taxes on fossil fuel products have been significantly reduced in the past two years.
If you thought that the Eurozone is an anomaly across the world in reducing their attempts to control fossil fuel use, think twice. It’s common news that the US -- one of the biggest contributors to carbon emissions -- pulled out of the Paris Agreement last year. China and the US, who, as per a Yale environment report, contribute close to 45% of the global carbon emissions, have only increased their emissions in the past year. China has even started exporting coal technology to Third World nations.
If controlling global supply of crude oil could have worked, the fact is that the US, along with Russia, and of course the OPEC bloc of 15 nations -- the largest oil producers -- have, over the years, increased crude oil production to such an extent that WTI crude oil is trading at historic lows close to $50 levels.
Compare this to the $90 levels it was trading at in 2014.
So, what gives? Are significant economic blocs like the Eurozone, the US, China, and others deliberately ignoring global warming reduction efforts, in order to support their economic growth and local businesses, while attempting to push the opposite holier-than-thou philosophy of cleaning the environment down the throat of lesser-developed nations?
On the face of it, this is true. Developed nations are facing slower global growth, and realize that effecting emission controls will only reduce their growth further. Yet, they continue harping on the emissions that the lesser developed and developing nations are contributing.
Yes, the Paris Agreement has allowed developing and least developed nations time till 2030 to start reducing emissions, but it’s no secret that the UN -- or rather, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change -- has kept upping the ante on emerging nations to reduce emissions.
The fact is that when the world’s most developed nations are playing truant in controlling global warming, why should lesser developed and developing nations look at the 2030 deadline with any sort of urgency?
Why should the businesses of these emerging nations suffer from taxes on fuel or other forms of carbon clampdowns, when the most developed nation in the world backs out from previously signed climate control agreements, and when even the frontrunner in climate control, France, is unable to impose the same?
This is not to say that emissions are good for us -- they are not. This is also not to say that emissions leading to increased city pollution levels are to be embraced -- there are better ways to reduce air pollution than fuel taxes. This is simply to say that governments of emerging economies should definitely ignore any attempts by international bodies to initiate carbon tax measures in their economies even if developed economies reverse their current attitude of ignoring global warming.
A fresh and burgeoning economy, with sprouting entrepreneurships and growth of innovation-driven businesses -- which is resulting in wider and higher per-capita incomes across the nation -- need not experiment with any attempts that can have devastating effects on domestic businesses and national economic growth.
To this extent, the protesting French civilians are similar to businesses in emerging nations, as carbon taxes hit them the most than the already established big businesses and behemoth economies. Perhaps this is the time for us to salute the gilets jaunes in giving a revolutionary answer to the carbon tax brigade.
Ananthanarayanan Sandeep is the Group CEO of STS Group, co-author of the strategy best-seller Cult, and guest faculty of strategy at IIM Calcutta.



