Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

A commission of spines?

Update : 10 Feb 2017, 05:13 PM

As I was pondering over federal judge James Robart’s order of last week that put in temporary abeyance on President Trump’s immigration and refugees order, my thoughts turned to the ongoing reconstitution of the Election Commission in Bangladesh.

In my limited understanding of constitutional law, President Trump’s order was well within his rights as the chief executive of the land, so I am not sure I get where Judge Robart was coming from. But the jurist’s spine certainly impressed me: Here is a lonesome judge at the first rung of the federal judiciary in faraway Seattle who just signed away any possibility of being elevated to the appellate bench since he interfered with the policy of his own party’s president, a policy supported by at least half, if not more, of the population.

It is that spine that matters and has mattered in the saga of Election Commissions (EC) in Bangladesh, ever since the end of the caretaker government provision.

The immediate past chief election commissioner (CEC) and his fellow commissioners were not bad men; indeed they were very qualified and credentialed like the best of civil servants.

The number of seminars they had attended on election supervision around the world must have run into several dozen between the five of them.

I don’t even think that the past EC set out to be partisan or biased.

The CEC and his colleagues, by all ostensible measures, seemed to be decent, disinterested chaps trying to find their way in a hapless situation that was created when the caretaker government provision was removed.

That hapless situation, where a very politicised administration is managing an election to curry favour with a very political government with tentacles in every edifice of institutional society, called for spines of steel in the national panel supervising elections.

Unfortunately for the previous EC, never mind steel, they didn’t even manage to have pliable aluminum buffeting their spinal cords.

Now, I am not unaware of the fact that statutorily the authority of the EC leaves a lot to be desired in Bangladesh. But even within those constrains of authority, the previous EC did not lift a finger when journalists were beaten to pulp, ministers were breaking canvassing regulations with glee, and law enforcement was standing idly by as millions of ballot papers were stamped by ruling party hoodlums in open daylight.

Unfortunately for the previous EC, never mind steel, they didn’t even manage to have pliable aluminum buffeting their spinal cords

And that is not even touching on the rampant intimidation, threats, and gun-slinging that went on behind the glare of the cameras.

Under the law even as it is written imperfectly, the EC has the plenary right to call for the deployment of the armed forces in support of civil power during elections; the previous CEC studiously refrained from doing so.

If such pliancy has assured him an ambassadorship in Western Europe somewhere, I am happy for him; otherwise, he may have sold his spine and conscience short.

That’s all in the past.

In looking to the future, it is a cause for a little bit of optimism that the president consulted stake-holders and parties to form a search committee which, in turn, did the same before submitting names for the next EC. Again, the folks in the new panel look to be impressive insofar as their resumes go.

Most of them are not particularly partisan, though about a couple of them I have certain concerns, given the mystery surrounding the genesis of their nominations.

None of that will matter if the new EC -- as a collective entity and in the form of its constituent members -- realises that its job of holding free and fair elections, by the very definition of Bangladesh’s political culture, means standing up to the machinations of executive authority and its subsidiaries in the bureaucratic and political realm.

The toughest job of a CEC and his EC is to say “no” to the organic desire of any ruling party of the day to tilt the playing field by bureaucratic machination, plain and old-fashioned street violence, and simple disobedience to the lawful edicts of the commission.

This tough job of standing, to paraphrase the late William F Buckley, athwart the gush of power and saying “no” is the foundation of anything meaningful that the new EC may or may not do. The rest of it is details.

If this Election Commission can say a loud and clear “no” to the executive, the ruling party, the ruling party’s so-called “student” wing, and assorted bottom-feeders who feast on sycophancy, it will be a resounding success.

Otherwise, this commission will be no different than its lamentable predecessor or the electoral authorities of such democratic heavens like North Korea, Iran, and Cuba.

Esam Sohail is an educational research analyst and college lecturer of social sciences. He writes from Kansas, USA.

Top Brokers