Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Recall our man in Islamabad

Update : 11 Dec 2015, 06:19 PM

Count me amongst those who are absolutely convinced of the necessity of the war crimes trials and equally unconvinced that they are proceeding under internationally recognised norms of fairness and due process.

I put that disclaimer out there lest readers jump to the conclusion that this is just another ranting of a latter-day chetona aficionado who is more pro-government than the government itself.

This government, controversial as its mandate may be, should do the respectable thing with regards to Pakistan and recall the Bangladesh high commissioner in Islamabad.

It is a symbolic move, and as a practical man, I don’t put much stock in symbolism for its own sake; nonetheless, in this case it may be the most constructive response to the Nawaz Sharif government’s sudden onset of historical amnesia.

I can understand the concept of national pride and the existence of different versions of history. That jingoism often informs the respective narratives of 1971 for Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh is but a reflection of human vanity that has been in existence since the first tablets of war history were inscribed in Babylon.

The Pakistan government’s denial of “any involvement” in the genocide of 1971, however, is not an exercise in mere jingoism but an illustration of a malady that rightly cries out for some therapy in the contours of the truth.

Prime Minister Sharif’s government is not saying that it disputes the extent of the genocide … it is essentially asserting that it never happened! Proof to the contrary is legion and legendary, and I need not repeat the well-known except to point out two very Pakistani sources of the era themselves.

One was Pakistan’s premier journalist, the late Anthony Mascarenhas who termed it the “ugliest genocide in history since WWII”; the other was Islamabad’s own Hamoodur Rehman Commission Report which, even while trying to blame “separatist elements,” made no bones about the excesses of the Pakistani military during its last year in its former eastern wing. 

The command responsibility for these “excesses” didn’t exactly go up to some aliens in Mars or Jupiter; the culpability rests squarely on many of those who were majors, colonels, and generals of the Pakistan Army then, and now are either off to their heavenly rewards or reaping their tax-payer funded plots of lands in fertile Punjab.

It is not the degree of a historical event that the Islamabad government quarrels with; it is the very existence of that event it denies. It needs to be called out on this, and thus helped with this pathological condition of temporary amnesia.

How better to do it than the symbolic yet jarring instance of recalling the chief envoy of a sovereign people and let the world notice the reasons behind it?

I am a well-wisher of Pakistan and, as a realist, know very well how important to the economy is the continuation and enhancement of the robust trade ties between Pakistan and Bangladesh. Nor am I unaware of the fact that a long shared history means that there are many people in both countries who share bonds of family and professional relationships with each other. And then there is, of course, cricket (enough said)!

Any action to make these relationships more difficult to maintain is wrong on both moral and practical levels, and sends the highly contemptible message that the people of Bangladesh have disregard for Pakistani people, many of whom bravely stood up for Bangladesh in the dark days of 1971.

Recalling the high commissioner does no such wrong. Rather, it sends the right message to the right recipients without cutting off the diplomatic links that are vital facilitators of professional, sporting, familial, and trade relationships.

This would not be a merely symbolic move that simply results in a high commissioner (or two, in case Islamabad responds in kind) getting some much needed unscheduled vacations.

Very possibly such an action could result in drawing attention to the facts on the ground and helping sober, thinking heads prevail in Pakistani policy-making again. There is some potential practical value in the gesture which also, of course, assuages the outrage of many others on an emotional level.

It is time to send a message to the Nawaz Sharif government that can be therapeutic and help his ministers jolt back to the realm of reality.

Recall the high commissioner Suhrab Hossain back to Dhaka. 

Top Brokers