Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Singapore this ain’t

Update : 06 Nov 2015, 07:11 PM

That authoritarianism is the elixir to prosperity and progress is a mantra which has found strong resonance in the territory which became Pakistan in 1947: From the days of Ghulam Mohammad through Ayub Khan through Ziaul Huq, from BKSAL through Ershad through the present day.

Sporadic bursts of democratic openness had done little to allay deep seated mistrust amongst ideological elites that pluralism, fair elections, and individual liberty were singularly unsuited to the temperament of their more benighted fellow citizens.

Intelligent people not affiliated with the ruling party shouldn’t be surprised that such sentiments, albeit couched in terms of “our version of Westminster” or “Singapore style democracy,” are now openly expressed by those in office without a single ballot being cast in their favour.

In fairness to the disposition of such elites, the desire to not give up state power is a very human character flaw, a flaw made all the more alluring by the fact that, in Bangladesh, such power ensures material riches, impunity from any accountability for criminal conduct, and a smooth path for easily settling one’s children and grandchildren abroad, thanks to control over patronage jobs and scholarships.

Beyond the personal benefits of being autocrats, I will admit that in some jurisdictions, such an approach to governance has indeed helped bring about material blessings for citizens. In the broader neighbourhood, Singapore, Dubai, and Hong Kong come to mind almost immediately in this regard.

It is not coincidental that these entities -- and especially Singapore amongst them -- are the favourite examples for the purveyors of the ruling party line who want us to ignore the creeping march towards a de facto one party state.

A fundamental problem with such a rosy comparison is that all those three favourites of third world autocrats have something that is empirically beyond imagination in Bangladesh: A near lack of widespread corruption.

Year after year, Transparency International has found Singapore, the United Arab Emirates (of which Dubai is a constituent sheikhdom), and Hong Kong to be amongst the cleanest 25 jurisdictions in the world in terms of transparency of public dealings and institutional corruption.

Where Bangladesh stands on that score is all too well-known to need reminding. Such a perception of clean dealings is vital, of course, for countries and cities whose economy rests on their roles as pre-eminent hubs of trade, commerce, investment, and ancillary services.

Coupled with that image of public integrity is the deeply ingrained desire of these governments -- as authoritarian as they are -- to take a largely laissez-faire approach to business; such a hands-off outlook on commerce is hard to imagine in a country where the national flag carrier proudly serves as a tax-payer white elephant and the public tender process is routinely used as a means to reward “student activists” of the ruling party.

But fiscal discipline and public integrity are not the only two things that keep the veneer of legitimacy on many such authoritarian regimes. In the case of both Hong Kong and Singapore, the judiciary is widely seen to function with incredible freedom, in collaboration with very professional bars and independent police services.

Even with a plethora of laws, often considered harsh by many human rights organisations, both these jurisdictions provide a machinery for administering justice that is efficient, transparent, and fiercely independent of the executive and the party for the most part. Such a robust judiciary is all the more telling in Hong Kong, considering it is technically a part of the People’s Republic of China, albeit with a governance setup that reflects its unique history.

In Singapore’s case, the authoritarianism of the ruling People’s Action Party comes with an additional twist that adds credibility in a manner that is hard to imagine in Bangladesh in the aftermath of the electoral exercise of April this year and January of last year.

The orderliness, transparency, and openness of the Singapore general elections are legendary; the idea that ruling party hacks or policemen would barge in and rubber stamp ballots in broad daylight is an alien concept in that city-state.

Votes cast are votes tallied under the supervision of a professional cadre of powerful and impartial election officers. None other than the National Geographic -- a magazine routinely critical of totalitarian societies -- admitted this paradoxical fact about Singapore’s elections in a profile on the country earlier this year.

That opposition parties have not made much headway in Singapore’s politics has more to do with the ethnic makeup and narrow appeal of the tiny opposition parties. Singapore is hardly a model of Westminster democracy, but certainly a far more real example than Bangladesh today.

So, sure keep peddling authoritarianism by pointing to its supposed success stories, but make sure it is understood what comes in exchange for such dubious legitimacy: Corruption-free public administration, free markets, independent police and judiciary, and absence of “student front” hooliganism and intimidation.

Is Bangladesh able to make that exchange? Any sane person would doubt that. Why not, then, bring back the inefficient but vibrant pluralist democracy we used to have between 1990 and 2014? Ah … there is the conundrum of the base instincts of human character. 

Top Brokers